From Poly to Swan...will we be disappointed??

Dominion

Mouseketeer
Joined
Feb 3, 2013
Messages
322
My family stayed at the Poly about two years ago in club level rooms and had an amazing time. It was our first family trip and I booked the trip almost a year in advance, did ADRs at 180 days out, character meals, BBB for my daughter and nieces, etc... It was an amazing trip! I really want to take my kids this fall and I have tentatively booked a room at the Swan for 6 nights. I'm staying using Starwood points so my cost will be $23/day for the room. I'm booking everything later so don't think we'll get any character meal ADRs. Will my kids be disappointed in the change from the Poly to the Swan? The monorail made going to MK and EPCOT so easy and it really was kind of a magical stay. I just don't want it to seem like a downer after the last trip...would love some opinions or experience with similar situations.

Thanks!
 
Swan is walking distance to Epcot & Hollywood Studios so there is no magic lost there in terms of local. Also you can walk over it the boardwalk at night for entertainment.

I think there are plenty of character meals available after the 180 day mark . There is one at the Swalfin even ( Garden Grove) I would focus on taking advantage of that location. Look at Cape May & Epcot restaurants. Get hoppers & spend each night at WS enjoying the food. Make a point to explore the boardwalk & rebt a surrey bike. Mini golf is also right there.

The beauty of WDW is that magic is literally at every turn. You just need to look for it.
 
We were very disappointed in the Swan. We also stayed on points but the resort fees, hotel parking fees, credit card holds for incidentals, and very high food cost in "food court" we're shocking. We could have stayed at a Disney resort cheaper even with our points. Great location but it did not feel like Disney.
 
My family stayed at the Poly about two years ago in club level rooms and had an amazing time. It was our first family trip and I booked the trip almost a year in advance, did ADRs at 180 days out, character meals, BBB for my daughter and nieces, etc... It was an amazing trip! I really want to take my kids this fall and I have tentatively booked a room at the Swan for 6 nights. I'm staying using Starwood points so my cost will be $23/day for the room. I'm booking everything later so don't think we'll get any character meal ADRs. Will my kids be disappointed in the change from the Poly to the Swan? The monorail made going to MK and EPCOT so easy and it really was kind of a magical stay. I just don't want it to seem like a downer after the last trip...would love some opinions or experience with similar situations.

Thanks!

Well, the Poly at CL is definitely a step above the Swan for $23 per night! I am sure that you spent quite a bit more $$$ that time around. So, fair enough, it will be different. Would you really want to do the same trip again? We like the variety of staying in different resorts for different trips. It is more fun for us.

The Swan is a great hotel and the location is wonderful. You will find a difference, but as Fastpassminus said, it is largely in the attitude that you bring. A great WDW vacation is possible even if staying in a value resort. HOWEVER, you are still staying in a true luxury resort on Disney property within walking distance of two theme parks! That is a dream vacation in most peoples estimation.
In fact, We often choose to stay at the Swan instead of staying in one of the WDW resorts. WE LOVE the comfortable beds in the Swan, we enjoy the great dining at the Swan/Dolphin. WE like the location that is the closest to halfway between the DHS and Epcot. We enjoy the Grotto pool. Finally, in our opinion, you just can't beat the price that we usually get for that caliber of hotel in that location.

Don't expect the trip to be the same as last time. It will be different - but that can be in a good way. Enjoy World Showcase being right next door. Walk around the Boardwalk in the evening and interact with the buskers. Try doing a Behind the Scenes tour or have Afternoon Tea at the GF with your daughter. Book an Illuminations cruise. Book other character meals or different dining experiences that you missed last time. Yes, the last trip was magical but this one can be magical as well!!!

If you really would miss the Poly, how about a split stay where you spend the beginning of the trip at the Swan and then move to the Poly for the lat 2-3 nights? that way you keep prices relatively low, but you still get a little of the nostalgia of the magic of the last trip.

Whatever you decide, have a wonderful vacation!
 

Well, the Poly at CL is definitely a step above the Swan for $23 per night! I am sure that you spent quite a bit more $$$ that time around. So, fair enough, it will be different. Would you really want to do the same trip again? We like the variety of staying in different resorts for different trips. It is more fun for us.

The Swan is a great hotel and the location is wonderful. You will find a difference, but as Fastpassminus said, it is largely in the attitude that you bring. A great WDW vacation is possible even if staying in a value resort. HOWEVER, you are still staying in a true luxury resort on Disney property within walking distance of two theme parks! That is a dream vacation in most peoples estimation.
In fact, We often choose to stay at the Swan instead of staying in one of the WDW resorts. WE LOVE the comfortable beds in the Swan, we enjoy the great dining at the Swan/Dolphin. WE like the location that is the closest to halfway between the DHS and Epcot. We enjoy the Grotto pool. Finally, in our opinion, you just can't beat the price that we usually get for that caliber of hotel in that location.

Don't expect the trip to be the same as last time. It will be different - but that can be in a good way. Enjoy World Showcase being right next door. Walk around the Boardwalk in the evening and interact with the buskers. Try doing a Behind the Scenes tour or have Afternoon Tea at the GF with your daughter. Book an Illuminations cruise. Book other character meals or different dining experiences that you missed last time. Yes, the last trip was magical but this one can be magical as well!!!

If you really would miss the Poly, how about a split stay where you spend the beginning of the trip at the Swan and then move to the Poly for the lat 2-3 nights? that way you keep prices relatively low, but you still get a little of the nostalgia of the magic of the last trip.

Whatever you decide, have a wonderful vacation!

Thanks, this makes a lot of sense. The reasons you list here are pretty much the ones that led me to the Swan, in addition to the fact that the room is paid for in points plus a little cash. I just wasn't sure about the location since we will still spend half of our touring days at the MK. And I forgot to mention that my then 3.5 year old's favorite "ride" was the monorail ;-) Hopefully that will have changed in almost 2 years!! I definitely don't want it to be the same trip and my attitude towards planning it has been different for sure - I'm taking a more relaxed approach and hoping that translates into a more relaxed trip. Last time there were 10 of us, we had lots of ADRs and other scheduled things and that made for some stress that I would rather avoid this time around.

Are there some casual places on the Boardwalk that we can eat at without an ADR? I'm fine with going to WS, but definitely want to avoid it on Friday and Saturday nights because of F/W crowds, but I think we will do Il Mulino and Garden Grove those evenings.

Also, can you tell me what the easiest breakfast options are at the Swan? I haven't been able to find that information yet. Thank you!
 
We were very disappointed in the Swan. We also stayed on points but the resort fees, hotel parking fees, credit card holds for incidentals, and very high food cost in "food court" we're shocking. We could have stayed at a Disney resort cheaper even with our points. Great location but it did not feel like Disney.

And these are the things I've heard about that make me nervous! I won't have a car, but my parents will so that does increase costs for sure. What do you mean by "credit card holds for incidentals"?? What is that about? And can you give me a more specific idea on the food court prices? Is that Picabu?
Thank you!
 
We were very disappointed in the Swan. We also stayed on points but the resort fees, hotel parking fees, credit card holds for incidentals, and very high food cost in "food court" we're shocking. We could have stayed at a Disney resort cheaper even with our points. Great location but it did not feel like Disney.

I agree. After all the EXTRA CHARGEs (sneaky and annoying).....
 
And these are the things I've heard about that make me nervous! I won't have a car, but my parents will so that does increase costs for sure. What do you mean by "credit card holds for incidentals"?? What is that about? And can you give me a more specific idea on the food court prices? Is that Picabu?
Thank you!

Yes, the "food court" is Picabu, and I don't remember specific prices on anything. You should check out the Swan & Dolphin thread...lots of good info there.
 
Thanks, this makes a lot of sense. The reasons you list here are pretty much the ones that led me to the Swan, in addition to the fact that the room is paid for in points plus a little cash. I just wasn't sure about the location since we will still spend half of our touring days at the MK. And I forgot to mention that my then 3.5 year old's favorite "ride" was the monorail ;-) Hopefully that will have changed in almost 2 years!! I definitely don't want it to be the same trip and my attitude towards planning it has been different for sure - I'm taking a more relaxed approach and hoping that translates into a more relaxed trip. Last time there were 10 of us, we had lots of ADRs and other scheduled things and that made for some stress that I would rather avoid this time around.

Are there some casual places on the Boardwalk that we can eat at without an ADR? I'm fine with going to WS, but definitely want to avoid it on Friday and Saturday nights because of F/W crowds, but I think we will do Il Mulino and Garden Grove those evenings.

Also, can you tell me what the easiest breakfast options are at the Swan? I haven't been able to find that information yet. Thank you!

Il mulino and the garden grove are good choices for those days. There are a few places at the BWI, but we usually eat at Pica ou if we aren't eating in a theme park or TS. My fav breakfast location is fresh at the Dolphin. They have great fresh juices. I particularly like to get the continental buffet which includes all the cold offerings along with hot oatmeal for 15.99 per adult. Lots of fruit, muffins and pastries. Yum!

The Garden Grove serves breakfast at the Swan, but we haven't eaten there for breakfast. We often have breakfast foods in the room to eat while getting ready in the mornings. Foods that are easy like muffins and fruit or bread with pb and jam. Small boxes of cold cereal. We keep juice and milk in the fridge. Then we have a more substantial lunch around noon.

Quick service locations include Picabou next door, the bakery at the BW and the Marketplace at the BC. The QS dining is limited in the Epcot area resorts, IMO. Sorry, if there are others, I'm not aware of them. As I said, breakfast is where we often cheat and eat in the room. saves some $$$. You can look at resort restaurants and menus at www.allears.net which should help you with planning your dining.

BtW, the fees at the Swan/Dolphin are resort fees of $23.00 per night per room and $18.00 parking fee for the car per day. Lots of people are upset by these. I know about them and add it into the cost of staying here. So, if you have a car, it is about $40 per day plus tax to stay here with points, I believe. We haven't been able to use points here so we usually pay for the rooms at a discounted rate. We add the $23 dollars to the rate to get our total. It still beats the prices at the BC and BWI for us. We don't have a car when at WDW. We booked the Dolphin for nov for $180 per night with nurses discount, which really means $203 per night. That is a great rate for an Epcot resort, IMO, but it is still quite a bit more than your $40 per night. I am not sure where you can stay in WDW for $40 per night anymore? Especially in the Epcot resort area?

BTW, credit card holds for incidentals refers to a hotel putting a hold on your credit card tfor a limited amount to cover resort purchases during your stay, I think. That means that you cannot spend that money elsewhere. If you don't have any incidental charges, then the cc hold is released at check out. It is a way for the hotel to ensure that they won't get stuck without payment for charges to the room. This is something that many hotels do, but not other 'real' WDW resorts, as far as I know.

If you are eating in the Swan or Dolphin, ask if they give discounts for anything that you have such as AAA. They may do so. Also, on my last visit to the Dolphin I mentioned the $10 per person charge for no shows that Disney charges. Their reply was that Disney doesn't know if you eat there or not and that they do not have that policy. Just one little benefit if you find yourself unable to make it to a dining reservation for some reason. Ask when you arrive, to be sure of that, though. Policies change and misinformation is sometimes given. Also I am not advocating bookings without planning to show up or not calling to let them know of changes in plans, but, with Disney, you have to cancel a full 24 hours or pay $10 per person if you miss the resservation. That $10 includes $10 for children under 2 that you wouldn't even need to pay for a meal for! Sometimes WDW transportation can leave you waiting or stuck on a monorail for hours. It is nice to know that you won't be charged $10 per person in that sort of situation.

Riding the monorail is still possible, even if you aren't staying in a monorail resort. Visit the resorts anyway for a meal or a break. It is a fun way to get a quick break from the MK and relax mid day if you want a change but don't want to return to the Swan.
 
I'm booking everything later so don't think we'll get any character meal ADRs.

Don't forget that you DON'T need a room reservation to do ADRs at 180 days. You can't book your whole length of stay, but you can make dining reservations!

Have fun planning!
 
We've stayed at either the swan or dolphin, can't remember off the top of my head but I remember saying this is the first and last time. The lobby was beautiful and the grounds are very nice. Being close to a few things are great too but the room was just terrible. I've stayed at $90 hotels that were nicer. The a/c was awful, room never got below 77 or something, there was at least 5 layers of paint covering everything including the hinges, rooms are small like the values which are fine if I'm paying value price, hallways were very worn. Luckily I was able to get a discount and only paid $170 with other bs fees included. Next day we went to por and that blows this resort out of the water. I really don't know why you'd pay those fees plus parking daily when there are as good if not better choices that are Disney. If you do choose this place, enjoy your trip and I hope you have a great experience.
 
We've stayed at the Dolphin for a week in October back in 2011 and we absolutely loved it. We'd definitely stay there again and each trip we always book Shula's, bluezoo and Il Mulino no matter where we're staying.
And if you have park hoppers you could always take the monorail between Epcot and the Magic Kingdom to give your little one his monorail "fix".
 
I LOVE the Swan and Dolphin! The rooms are considerably larger than those at value resorts, and the Swan is finishing refurbishment of their rooms. (The Dolphin's rooms will get their re-do in 2016.) I spend a lot of time at Epcot, and I love being able to walk back to my room, rather than having to make the long walk to wait for a bus.

I know the Poly has a lot of fans, but it has never appealed to me. It's also outrageously priced!
 
I think location alone is enough to make Swan/Dolphin a great value. They are not usually as cheap as a moderate (with discounts, that is), but way cheaper than any deluxe, even with their extra fees included. Being able to walk/boat to 2 parks is a huge selling point for us. We have stayed at Dolphin twice now and enjoyed the location more than the rooms. Rooms at that time were rather dark and dated...but beds are very comfortable and the lobby is very pretty. Grounds are relaxing and you can walk around Boardwalk in the morning while waiting for Epcot to open up.
 
The hotels are very different from each other. We prefer either the Swan or the Dolphin to the Poly. The Epcot resort area has been our favorite for years. Now that we have a grandson and more grand babies on the way, that might change, lol. The S/D are straight up hotels and don't pretend to be anything else. The price is great. As for food costs, it hasn't been a blip because the food across WDW is overpriced.
The things nessz79 has posted also make the S/D attractive.

Dominion, if you go on this trip comparing it to your dream trip, you will be disappointed. You will likely never have the stars align exactly the same again for any trip. I say this because we took our then 5 year old son to WDW in 1989. It was absolutely perfect-weather, CMs, resort, crowds, etc. Not once since then have I had a WDW trip as nice as that one. Once I realized that I was comparing trips, I let go of my "perfect trip" expectations and I had much more fun. The S/D are not Disney, so don't expect that but they are nice hotels in a great location.
 
Our oldest son has been on several trips to Disney, starting when he was 2 1/2. The monorail is a favorite ride of his, too. He has only stayed at monorail resorts - and the Swan and Dolphin. We usually split between a monorail resort and the Swan or Dolphin so we can be near MK part of the time and Epcot/HS part of the time. He has enjoyed every trip (Contemporary, BLT, Poly several times), but he often says his favorite is the Triangle Hotel (Dolphin), despite a view of Space Mountain and Wishes from BLT on one trip, and a theme park view room at CR on New Years. He loved the pool at the Swan/Dolphin (Grotto pool), ice cream at the Fountain, the evening lights and entertainment on the Boardwalk. We hopped the monorail to MK from Epcot frequently. You can grab something at the Boardwalk Bakery for breakfast, but we usually just had yogurt or cereal in the room. From the grown up perspective, I preferred the rooms at Poly - I have a special place in my heart for that resort - and think the room upgrades at the Swan and Dolphin will be welcome, especially for the bathrooms. But I have booked Dolphin and Swan rooms on points, too, and you just can't compare that to Poly rates, with or without resort fees (which are essentially included in the significant rates at my beloved Polynesian). You can put that savings toward special dining experiences, a fireworks cruise (or two - one each for Wishes and Illuminations) or other fun vacation add ins. Or just put that $ toward your next stay - at Swan/Dolphin or Poly. By the way, as between the Swan and Dolphin, we had a preference for the Dolphin, and also found the points investment in a better view worthwhile. We absolutely would not hesitate to stay at the Dolphin again, and plan to. Good luck and enjoy your trip whatever you decide!
 
And these are the things I've heard about that make me nervous! I won't have a car, but my parents will so that does increase costs for sure. What do you mean by "credit card holds for incidentals"?? What is that about? And can you give me a more specific idea on the food court prices? Is that Picabu?
Thank you!

We had 2 reservations due to points for 2 nights and cash for 1 night. They put a $100 per night credit card hold on my account for " incidentals". We got it back after check out but we wanted that $300 for our trip.

Picabu is the "food court". We ate breakfast here 1 morning. I got a plain biscuit, an order of bacon and a coke and it was $18!!

Never again for us.

And, we are not new to Disney. We have been over 25 times in the last 13 years and AP holders. We always stay on site and switch between value, mod and deluxe resorts. We were definitely not treated the same here as at Disney resorts.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom