My family has eaten at both WCT and AG. We were not impressed with the WCT meals that we received at all, in fact we decided we didn't need to eat there ever again. BUT they've changed the menu since then so we would give it another shot to try the new menu.
We've eaten at AG many times, we have 2 DD's who are big Princess lovers so there are times we just walk up to see if we can get a table at AG. We love the menu there, the food has always been very good and most (if not all) gets devoured!! We don't like paying the higher price for DD10 but we would do it for her because DBF and I like the food there so much. DBF loves the Cioppino, gets it almost every time, DD14 loves the tri tip, gets it almost every time, personally I've had the tri tip, the agnolotti pasta, the chicken, they've all been excellent, we've never had a miss at AG! The appetizers are good, I love the salad that they serve and could eat just that if they'd let me, the salami, cheese, veggies, bread and butters are all good, the only thing off the appetizer platter that doesn't get finished is the jello, we aren't big jello eaters. DBF will usually eat one or two cubes but that's about it. The dessert platter is very good, I love the cheesecakes tarts with raspberries and no one else does (not big cheesecake eaters in my family) so I get them all, and we mostly split everything else, it's all fresh and very good.
Actually, here's a link to the menu for you.
http://www.themouseforless.com/tripplanning/menus/dl/arielsgrotto.shtml
and I have had the chicken at both AG & BB, I thought the chicken was better at AG.
