The views are similar from both locations, so I personally would base it on what you're willing to pay and what your expectations are from the experience. The Rose and Crown fireworks package could be a lot cheaper (depending on # of guests) and includes dinner with drinks, so that's a plus. The boats are fun and feel more special (at least to us), but they only have snacks and soda/water, so no meal or alcohol unless you pay extra or bring your own. Plus if there is lightning within a couple of miles they will cancel the cruise which happened to us this past fall and was a big disappointment.