For birthday- Chef Mickey's or O'hana after fireworks?

[Hannahan]

I have a specialty cruise scheduled for next week and would like to also catch the water pageant. Since CR and Poly are accessible to both, which would be a better dinner choice? We are celebrating birthday's for DD-11 and DS-3 and will also have DD-1 with us. Any suggestions?

 

[m&m's mom]

I have similar dilemma.
We are staying to Poly this time but always have tradition of going to Chef Mickey's on our first night. We are thinking about changing to O'Hana's to start closer to "home".
I think Chef Mickey's is so-so and O'Hana's has so many mixed reviews I am not sure.
I will be watching for others thoughts.

 

[skiwee1]

What time are the fireworks scheduled for? I ask because it might be too late to eat with kids that age. If your kids aren't used to eating dinner at 10pm then they might not enjoy it. Maybe you can eat before you go on the cruise. As far as choices I would go for Chef Mickey, especially for a birthday. Ohana is great too but CM is more fun for the kids at that age.