The Magic Kingdom was open until 3am the day we were there, so after lunch we took a nice long break and arrived at the Contemporary all fresh and rested. We checked in on the 2nd floor about 5 minutes before our ADR time and were taken right up to the restaurant.
I love the stroller check here; it is so nice to leave it with the hostess on the 2nd floor and not think about it again until you're ready to leave!
Once upstairs we were given a pager and went down the hallway to the restroom. DD2 likes cleaning up for dinner here because they have a sink that is just her size. For a toddler in the "do it myself" stage, that's true luxury.

We'd barely gotten our hands washed when the pager started buzzing.
We were seated at a wonderful table off to the lounge side of the restaurant, right at the window with a wonderful view of the Magic Kingdom. The sun was just starting to set and they had the semi-sheer shades down to block the glare but they don't entirely block the view.
Our server was Ellen, and she was simply delightful, just conversational enough without being overly chatty and very aware of our needs. She suggested drinks for the girls that were something like a Shirley Temple but made with Sprite instead of ginger ale, and brought a small dish of maraschino cherries along with the one that came in each drink.
California Grill serves goldfish crackers with the bread course, one of several small touches that make it the most child-friendly of the signature restaurants in my opinion, and that really got the evening off to a good start with the girls. They were both a bit hungry and aren't big fans of sourdough, so having their own "bread" was perfect.
Ellen also brought the girls' appetizer out ahead of ours, a thoughtful touch. They ordered the fruit cup, which as always here had more variety of fruit in a cuter presentation than you find at other Disney restaurants.
It is a really little thing, but that's what make the signatures signature - you can tell that the fruit cups here aren't plated in advance like they seem to be at most one credit restaurants. Apples and bananas are such kid favorites, but you don't often find them served in mixed fruit assortments because they begin to lose their color and texture so quickly after cutting. This was clearly freshly prepared, and the girls loved having it to snack on while we watched the sun set.
For an appetizer I ordered my usual - the spicy kazan roll from the sushi menu.
"Spicy Kazan Roll - crab, shrimp, bay scallops, tuna and fireball sauce"
This is heaven on a plate. Sweet, cool, fresh seafood wrapped in sticky rice and absolutely perfect seaweed that is never even a little bit tough like it can be in less upscale sushi restaurants, all topped with a sauce that is both flavorful and very spicy, with the tempura crunch topping to add texture. the pairing of sweet crab and scallops and the fireball sauce is delicious, and this remains my favorite sushi dish. Not just at Disney, but anywhere.
DM ordered the lobster salad, which comes and goes from the menu seasonally and isn't on any I can find online.
This was quite delightful. Chilled, sweet seafood (lobster and crab) in a very light dressing, with a delicious avocado cream accompaniment on the plate. DM loved it (as did DH when he tried it on our first visit to CG).
For my entree, I tried something new to the menu.
"Dragon roll - Spicy and Tataki Tuna with Shrimp Tempura, Bell Pepper, Avocado, and Chili Soy Glaze"
This replaced the Snake in the Grass, which was a barbeque eel roll that on the dining plans counts as an entree rather than an appetizer. The same is true for this new roll, and the price is the same ($26). As you can see from the pic, the portion is huge for sushi - it is a long roll and a very thick one, with spicy tuna and tempura shrimp inside and tuna and avocado rolled on the outside.
This was excellent, incredible, amazing. I adore sushi and I've never been disappointed in Yoshi's creations at California Grill. The sushi is really the reason we keep coming back. The tuna was nicely chilled and as always perfectly fresh with just the right texture, and the tempura shrimp paired nicely to make this a very "meaty", filling roll. The avocado added just a little creaminess and the accompanying sauce was just slightly spicy and slightly salty without being overwhelming. DD2 really liked this one as well; she ate one whole piece on her own (the fireball sauce kept her away from my appetizer).
DM ordered the veal, something that tends to be hard to find prepared well here at home.
"Cast Iron-seared Veal Tenderloin with Sweet Potato and Applewood Bacon Hash, Chanterelles, and Port Syrup"
The veal was prepared just right, nicely crusted but medium-rare inside. The sweetness of the potato hash contrasted well with the earthiness of the meat and the richness of the chanterelles. The meat itself was amazingly tender and flavorful, and the whole dish just worked perfectly.
DD9 ordered her usual as well. She loves macaroni and cheese but only homemade, no Kraft or Stouffers type, and on our first visit here she was thrilled to see that they serve a housemade mac & cheese that was to her liking.
The was good as always, creamy and just a bit sharp with a nice blend of cheeses. The girls had plenty to share, especially with DD9 sampling DM's veal and DD2 trying my sushi.
For dessert, again I went with my usual - the valhrona chocolate cake - and DM ordered the same.
This is something of a signature dessert at the California Grill and it is always on the menu, but the ice cream/sorbet pairing with the cake changes seasonally and can make or break the dish in my opinion. This pairing was one I've never been lucky enough to catch before - strawberries. Since they are in season right now, it was housemade Plant City strawberry ice cream and compote. There is nothing quite as nice as the combination of chocolate and strawberry, and this was a warm, dense chocolate cake with a rich, dark molten chocolate filling that went perfectly with the slightly tangy taste of the strawberry compote and the creamy strawberry ice cream. It was far better than the peppermint pairing I had on our '09 trip, but not quite as good as the blood orange accompaniments from '08.
The girls shared their usual too, the rice crispy sushi. Ellen brought it out pre-divided so that each girls would have their own chocolate "soy sauce" and marshmallow "wasabi" and "ginger", and it was cute as always.
I cannot say enough about the marvelous service we had for this dinner. Ellen kept our drinks refilled and even brought out a refill of the girls extra cherries while we were waiting for our entrees. The pacing of the meal was perfect, not rushed but not overly long either, and from start to finish dinner took about an hour and 40 minutes. During that time, we watched the amazing sunset, and after dark the girls were quite entertained with watching the castle change colors.
California Grill remains at the top of my must-do list as one of my favorite restaurants anywhere, my absolute favorite Disney restaurant, and right there with Flying Fish as the best meals of this trip.
Cost if paying OOP - $170.38
Total DxDDP value so far - $1139.86
A note on the DxDDP value - at this point in the trip we passed the breakeven point on the plan with 4 meals per person still remaining and only a handful of our snack credits added into the total.