Have you tried Akron Canton airport? It's very small, but always has direct flights to MCO. I used to fly Airtran from there to MCO, but this time used Southwest airline since the two are kind of merged. Just booked like not even two weeks ago for a week in June and round trip was $185/person. I have done around Xmas time before from there, but it was years ago so I don't remember the fares anymore. But I would try them as an airport, much cheaper than Cleveland and a lot of times when I search CLE, they don't have direct flights! That is strange to me because it's like a two hour and fifteen minute flight, why do I need a layover somewhere???