I feel for you. Our 1996 TV is starting to flicker and I'm afraid it is finally on it's last legs. Sad that we are needing to replace our 1996 TV while everyone I know who has flat screens are on their 2nd or 3rd TV in a lesser time span..
I'm going for a 50" Panasonic Plasma. $588 for the 1080p model at Sam's Club (compared to $699 everywhere else.) I don't like LCD at all. Every one I've ever viewed are just way too unrealistically bright and look horrible with sports. Plasma has more of a closer brightness look to a CRT picture. I'll stick with using LCD for the computer only (if I ever upgrade my 2005 computer with the 17 inch CRT, LOL.)
We just purchased a Panasonic 50" Plasma within the past month or so. We opted for the
UT model, which is a smart tv with 3D. It is a bit more expensive than the basic U line, but has a faster speed with displaying the picture (not sure of the word for it). Plasma also has a more true black over an LCD, with a glass screen like an old TV. They are also becoming more energy efficient and use less energy than most older LCDs.
The one major issue with viewing tv's in the store is a store mode setting that comes programmed into the TV. It is set for the brightest lighting, because stores are generally over lit. If you ask a sales person, they can change it to a normal house setting. It's also an overkill on the TV to leave it on a setting like that. Try going into the store late at night before closing when they have the lights a bit lower than day time.
Ours was purchased at
Best Buy, 4 year warranty, and they gave us $50 off a new tv stand. They were also running a promo with a free xbox 360, so that got sold and went to pay for the TV itself. Not to mention the 3 year 0% on the BB card, and now we've qualified for Silver Premier status with the reward zone points, and they offer free calibration for the TV.
It is a beautiful TV, and almost too big for this little apartment, but it fits ok along the wall.
Ohh make sure you have a darkened room for the TV, because of the glass screen, it does reflect more than an LCD or LED. We had to get blackout curtains in order for the window to not glare back (especially during dark scenes). Thankfully those were only $17 a panel at JcPenneys.