We did the fishing trip from YC in May. It was the 1st time fishing for my wife and 2 daughters. Our guide "Robert" was excellent. My wife caught a 4++lb bass, plus severl aothers. My 7 yr old caught a few, and I caught about 4.
Before going I thought that it was going to be a catching frenzy. It was anything but. We had to listen to our guide about various techniques and baits, only then did we catch fish.
We went on the 10am trip, the fish are less active. As per our guide, the 7am trip is always better.
Price was commensurate with return, we even received a discount because he said it was slow!! Gave a $20 tip on a bill of about $146
Bellmwr Bob
Disneydevotee