First trip to Hilton Head. WHere to eat?

Tigger1

DIS Veteran
Joined
Aug 18, 1999
Messages
2,107
In Route to Disney we are going to Hilton Head for 1 night. What is a good place to eat.for Seafood loverand not a seafood eater?

Also, what hotel for first night before Disneys Hilton Head?
 
So you are stopping for a night on way there...from NE I guess? We drive from PA so I can give recommends. How far do you want to get?

And we go to HHI all the time. For just 1 night there, maybe walk over into marina to Scott's for dinner. They have seafood and non seafood. They do happy hours too. And you can get a discount by showing your Disney resort room key. Has outdoor patio if warm enough for that (maybe they have heaters).

Another place is over by the Kroger in the Shelter Cove town center. It is called Poseidon. Huge place. Good seafood (sushi really good) and non seafood too. They also have outdoor patio. Also will give discount with showing Disney room key.
 
So you are stopping for a night on way there...from NE I guess? We drive from PA so I can give recommends. How far do you want to get?

And we go to HHI all the time. For just 1 night there, maybe walk over into marina to Scott's for dinner. They have seafood and non seafood. They do happy hours too. And you can get a discount by showing your Disney resort room key. Has outdoor patio if warm enough for that (maybe they have heaters).

Another place is over by the Kroger in the Shelter Cove town center. It is called Poseidon. Huge place. Good seafood (sushi really good) and non seafood too. They also have outdoor patio. Also will give discount with showing Disney room key.
This! It's one of our favorite restaurants on HHI. We go for early bird dining there and get the land and sea entree for $18.99. It's the only time I eat anything other than seafood while I'm on the island (well, except for One Hot Mama's bbq). That filet is delicious. It is very small, but they have larger filets and other steaks on their menu. They also have a large selection of seafood. The location is wonderful, very close to the Disney resort. We usually walk or ride our bikes to it.
 
So you are stopping for a night on way there...from NE I guess? We drive from PA so I can give recommends. How far do you want to get?

And we go to HHI all the time. For just 1 night there, maybe walk over into marina to Scott's for dinner. They have seafood and non seafood. They do happy hours too. And you can get a discount by showing your Disney resort room key. Has outdoor patio if warm enough for that (maybe they have heaters).

Another place is over by the Kroger in the Shelter Cove town center. It is called Poseidon. Huge place. Good seafood (sushi really good) and non seafood too. They also have outdoor patio. Also will give discount with showing Disney room key.
This may be crazy nut we are traveling from Oklahoma. It is about 2 extra hours to final destination, Orlando, but we really want to see Hilton Head. Plan is to leave on a Friday after work, travel all day Saturday and get a room as close to HH as possible. Then stat at DHH on Sunday. The two places you mentioned sound good. Thanks for the suggestions.
 

Another place is over by the Kroger in the Shelter Cove town center. It is called Poseidon. Huge place. Good seafood (sushi really good) and non seafood too. They also have outdoor patio. Also will give discount with showing Disney room key.
We ate Poseidon on our first HHI visit and liked it a lot. We plan to go back on our next visit.
 
We've never had a bad meal at Scott's and being walkable from DHH is great. For breakfast, The French Bakery is wonderful!
 
Sounds like Poseidon, Scotts and the French bakery are very good suggestions. Maybe one for lunch, the other for dinner and breakfast at the french bakery before heading to Disney. Where is the French Bakery?
 
/
The bakery is called Hilton Head Social bakery and is over in the marina near Scott's. Very yummy.
 
This may be crazy nut we are traveling from Oklahoma. It is about 2 extra hours to final destination, Orlando, but we really want to see Hilton Head. Plan is to leave on a Friday after work, travel all day Saturday and get a room as close to HH as possible. Then stat at DHH on Sunday. The two places you mentioned sound good. Thanks for the suggestions.
So I am not familiar with coming from that direction as we have always come from PA, MD or NC (3 places we have lived the past 25 years). So I know stops all along 95 going down to Disney. But Birmingham (6 hour 15 mins to HHI) and Atlanta (4 hour 10 mins) are big cities along your route and should have a ton of options. Macon if you want to get within 3 hours of HHI. During Covid, many of the free breakfast places don't have great offerings for free breakfast. Like Holiday Inn Express. Just a bag with like a banana, one place we stayed had a pear (yick), and granola bar. But we did a Hampton Inn that allowed dogs, because we had our dog with us, and they had a nice breakfast counter with hot items.

If you get to 95, there is Pooler. It isn't much but has some of the expected chain hotels right off 95 there. It is 47 mins to HHI.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like Poseidon, Scotts and the French bakery are very good suggestions. Maybe one for lunch, the other for dinner and breakfast at the french bakery before heading to Disney. Where is the French Bakery?
Another vote here for Scott's and the bakery. You can't beat the proximity plus the food is delicious.

Scott's gumbo and coconut shrimp are delicious and there is something for everyone at the bakery. Our favs there were the strawberry tartes, macarons, and something called Petite Bedouche. And they also have great iced coffees! Enjoy!! We love HH!
 
So is there 2 bakerys I want to try, Hilton Head Social bakery and the French Bakery?
 
So is there 2 bakerys I want to try, Hilton Head Social bakery and the French Bakery?
I haven't been to The French Bakery so can't attest to it.

But to clear up the confusion, the owner/baker of Hilton Head Social Bakery (next to Scott's) is an award-winning Frenchman--so we also refer to it as the French bakery.
 
This may be crazy nut we are traveling from Oklahoma. It is about 2 extra hours to final destination, Orlando, but we really want to see Hilton Head. Plan is to leave on a Friday after work, travel all day Saturday and get a room as close to HH as possible. Then stat at DHH on Sunday. The two places you mentioned sound good. Thanks for the suggestions.

I need to ask you what is meant by the above statement?

Because if you are thinking that it is only about 2 hours between Orlando and Hilton Head, you are off by at least 2 and 1/2 hours, maybe up to 3 depending on traffic. Usually 4 and 1/2 to 5 hours of travel time as its roughly 300 miles depending on your arrival point in Florida.

As to where to stop before arriving - tell us your route. I would tend to agree that Atlanta is a possibility, depending on where in Oklahoma you are leaving from. I'd probably do a 10 hour first day and try to do a shorter 2nd day.

As to where to eat, Poseidon is a great choice. First, it is very close to the resort so that your drive will be less than 5 minutes, it has decent food and both indoor and outdoor seating choices.

Scott's is 'ok'. It's a quick walk, and has a variety on the menu. The only time it may hit my radar is when I don't want to go anywhere, but would like to eat something.

Anyway, enjoy your trip! I'm hoping to be there Mid March.
 
I need to ask you what is meant by the above statement?

Because if you are thinking that it is only about 2 hours between Orlando and Hilton Head, you are off by at least 2 and 1/2 hours, maybe up to 3 depending on traffic. Usually 4 and 1/2 to 5 hours of travel time as its roughly 300 miles depending on your arrival point in Florida.

As to where to stop before arriving - tell us your route. I would tend to agree that Atlanta is a possibility, depending on where in Oklahoma you are leaving from. I'd probably do a 10 hour first day and try to do a shorter 2nd day.

As to where to eat, Poseidon is a great choice. First, it is very close to the resort so that your drive will be less than 5 minutes, it has decent food and both indoor and outdoor seating choices.

Scott's is 'ok'. It's a quick walk, and has a variety on the menu. The only time it may hit my radar is when I don't want to go anywhere, but would like to eat something.

Anyway, enjoy your trip! I'm hoping to be there Mid March.

I liked the menu selection more at Poseido than Scotts, thanks for the suggestion.

I meant the entire trip, one way, would be about 2 hours extra. Probably a bit more. It is 170 more miles than our usual route from Oklahoma to Disneyworld. We are leaving late the first day, so only driving 300 to 4oo miles. Hope to get to Hilton head second day, get a hotel somewhere near or at Hilton Head and then to Disneys Hilton the next next night.
 
As far as a place ON the Island, we have gotten fairly good rates in the past at the Hampton Inn near the HHI Airport. Nothing fancy, but we just wanted a bed for the night.
 
We've only been to Hilton Head once, but everywhere we ate was fantastic. I'll give you two entirely different suggestions that were our favorites.

Ela's on the Water was wonderful. It's a short (maybe 10 - 12 minute) walk from the Disney resort and the food and service were top notch. It's on the pricier side and more of an adult atmosphere, though we did see quite a few children in there and the wait staff seemed to be doing a great job interacting with them.

On the opposite end of the spectrum is Hudson's. If you love fresh seafood (they own their own shrimp boats) right on the docks, it's your place. You will have to drive there, though. We ran into an accident, so it took us a while to get there, but I'm guessing barring that it would have been about a 15 minute drive (??). It's extremely family friendly and the service was wonderful. The food isn't fancy, but it's fresh and delicious. Honestly it was some of the best coconut shrimp and shrimp & grits I've ever had.

Both places offer non seafood options.
 
We've only been to Hilton Head once, but everywhere we ate was fantastic. I'll give you two entirely different suggestions that were our favorites.

Ela's on the Water was wonderful. It's a short (maybe 10 - 12 minute) walk from the Disney resort and the food and service were top notch. It's on the pricier side and more of an adult atmosphere, though we did see quite a few children in there and the wait staff seemed to be doing a great job interacting with them.

On the opposite end of the spectrum is Hudson's. If you love fresh seafood (they own their own shrimp boats) right on the docks, it's your place. You will have to drive there, though. We ran into an accident, so it took us a while to get there, but I'm guessing barring that it would have been about a 15 minute drive (??). It's extremely family friendly and the service was wonderful. The food isn't fancy, but it's fresh and delicious. Honestly it was some of the best coconut shrimp and shrimp & grits I've ever had.

Both places offer non seafood options.
[/QUOT
Love the idea of Fresh Seafood. We do not mind to drive a little. I think we might try Hudsons.
 
I don’t have a seafood recommendation but my family loves One Hot Mamas if you want BBQ.
 



New Posts

















DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top