I agree Park Fare is great, but with the upcoming Cinderella meet, it seems to make sense to wait, or does it? Just a thought, but if your daughter likes it so much and meeting Cinderella, won't it be great to see Cinderella again? When kids that age are into something, they can never get enough, until that phase ends.
If you are looking for something fun and Disney to usher in the trip, this is a great idea.
Although Hoop de doo is great, on arrival night it may be a bit much esp. since 5 years old, while its super fun, sitting that long for those courses may be a bit much on arrival night. And while very fun, some of the humor and such may be more appreciated by the 7 to 11 crowd.
Sorry, none of us liked Chef Mickeys, we had to wait a lot, busier and less roomy than some of the other character dinners. IMO there are much better character dinners in terms of atmosphere. Id say food too, but that was just my opinion, the kids liked the food.
You have the great boat ride at your disposal, so a peaceful cruise down to Disney Springs does sound nice. If you cant get in to one of your other restaurants, Wolfgang Puck Express on the Marketplace side has great food. Its a step up from regular counter and nice variety of good food.
Another option if you transfer boats at DS is to go to OKW to Olivias where an ADR is usually not necessary.
One great tip too is to use the App on your phone for
MDE. I made ADRs on the fly and we chose from what was available. Ive actually made ADRs while we were on a bus to a resort and it was for when we got off the bus. But we are teens now and can easily get to wherever, split up, etc.,