We've eaten at 3 of the 4 listed.
We ate at Pecos Bill's last October for the first time - we thought that the burgers were really good (keeping in mind that we were at WDW!). I have always liked El Pirata, but we haven't been able to eat there in several years!
My whole family loves CHH - including me, and we eat there at least once per visit. BUT...for some reason, no matter what I eat, my stomach just can't deal well with the food, and I always end up a little sick . Not sure why, as it doesn't happen anywhere else!
CHH, but I also really like Casey's. I don't normally like hot dogs, but eating a hot dog from Casey's, sitting outside listening to Jim on the piano with the castle in the background just makes me feel like I'm on vacation every time.
I choose Cosmic Rays for lunch but for supper it would have to be Pecos Bill. Will be try CC this March for the first time so can't comment on that one. We love the burgers at CR and the chicken wrap at Pecos Bill.
If we decide to do an MK CS lunch (we always have a TS ADR in hand but sometimes cancel them at the last moment if our schedule changes), we tend to head for CHH (early, ergo before 11:30) and always grab a window table upstairs. It's nice to comfortably enjoy looking down at the outside mobs while eating!
I find them all to be mediocre, but chose CCH, since it seems to offer the most comfortable environment, and happens to be in a favorite park of the park for us.
For lunch, we prefer just to go to Casey's, grab some dogs and get back on our way.
Dreams Unlimited Travel is committed to providing you with the very best vacation planning experience possible. Our Vacation Planners are experts and will share their honest advice to help you have a magical vacation.