It's awesome to see the Peter Dominick resorts getting so much love here. Many said when I started out with Grand Cal and Wilderness Lodge that I'd have to get some points at Animal Kingdom before to long and they are right. I Just love all of them.
Here is how I'd rank them (only going to rank ones we have visited) -
Grand Cal - yea it's busy but it's also a stunning mix of Theme and Fancy that you don't get at most Disney/
DVC resorts.
Wilderness Lodge - On our 2nd trip to WDW and our first stay with our points we spent a few days at CCV and just loved it. The praise from our family (we were hosting 25 people at WDW for a reunion) was universal. It's a magical place.
Animal Kingdom (Jambo) - Just one step down from WL, Jambo does not disappoint. Also got tons of praise from the family for this place. I wish I would have captured photos of the look on the faces of that first look when you get past the doors and that first spot where the ceiling is lower. Magical.
Poly - I liked it a lot during our last visit and I'm very much looking forward to staying at some point in the near future.
Riviera - it's way too small and during some peak times it can be madness, but when it's not too crazy it's a great place to relax and the smell they use is just great.
Boardwalk - Our first visit and walkthrough the grounds was actually magical but I remember the lobby was nothing special. Would rank above Riviera if we were talking about the vibe on the lawn and the boardwalk. A great meal at Flying Fish for our 22nd moved this resort up a few spots in the want to stay category.
Grand Floridian - It's grand, but something just doesn't click. We'll have to visit more in the future and see if we are wrong.
SSR Carriage House - It's cute and we love the horses.
Contemporary - Love the mural and the monorail going through works I guess. It's just not a place I desire to visit.
OKW - It works with the theme and is functional. If we pull back and add in the other spaces and the open vibe might have to move this up a few spots. Love Olivia's and need to go back for more of that chicken...