About 4 yrs ago we went to Fantasmic! without any pkg. We were let into the arena about 1 hr before the show started, found our seats, and enjoyed the show.
3 yrs. ago, we had the Fantasmic! pkg. mainly because we planned on eating dinner in the park that evening anyway. We sat as close to the center as possible in that section and thought that our seats were as good as the ones we had previously.
Last yr., we went to Fantasmic! without the pkg. About 2 hrs. before the show started, the line was way down Sunset Blvd. We joined the line in hopes of getting seats. About 1 hr. before the show, they start letting people in. We did not realize there was another line coming from the other direction. It was a madhouse at the arena entrance. People were pushing and shoving. It was ridiculous. At that point we decided to leave the line and just go back to the hotel. All week the crowds were like that.
I have to say we were there the first week of June so it was much more crowded than January I'm sure. But, if you like just being able to walk right in and sit down, the meal pkg. is worth it to me. Sure, they're not the best seats, but at least it is a seat!!! JMHO.
I don't know if the pkg. would be necessary at a slower time of the year, but I'm definitely planning on having it this June!