We did the Fantasmic package at H&V, and the food wasn't the best. We did it twice, and the first time the food was ok, but the second time it was just wasn't good at all. However, I've been hearing lots of bad reviews about Mama Melrose's lately, so I think I would go with H&V anyway. The character meal should be fun, and I think it's just a hit-or-miss place. Hopefully you will have a good experience. As far as the Fantasmic package goes, you should be able to get a decent regular seat if you get to the theater early enough. I was never pleased with the reserved seats that are shoved on the extreme right side of the theater anyway.