Family's of 5...Where do you stay?

If you are comfortable with one bathroom then I say POR. We have 3 teen girls & did it with one bath no problem.
Wow ! I commend you Melsmice for making that work ! :thumbsup2 :worship:
I might do it for a 2 or 3 nights top. But for a week stay, we'd be miserable with 3 teens and dh and I in one room at POR---and that's exactly what I have (two teen girls and one teen boy). Sure shows how everyone is different and has different vacation needs/preferences.

I think I am in the minority here...but we felt sort of squished in POR. The trundle was really small and the kids argued about who would stay on it.
I'm with you Fivefordisney. We felt squished. Not so much when they were little, but now that they're not toddler/preschool anymore it sure feels tight.
I'm also with Linda in that disney does not guarantee connecting rooms. We have requested and been granted connecting about 75% of the time.....maybe a little less. The stays we did not get connecting prompted us to buy DVC. There was enough inconveniences in not getting our requests met that it had negatively impacted our vacations and we knew we wanted something that we knew we could count on. The times we did not get connecting, we at least got adjoining rooms.
 
Now I need to decide between--The Suite at All Star, 2 All Star Rooms or a Room at POR? Thoughts on those? I am thinking my kids will be 12, 9 and 7.

Help?

Oh and this may be our only trip, never been before and don't know if we will go back.

Go for POR:banana:

And take the extra $ to spoil yourself!:goodvibes
 
We are going in Jan 2008 and have booked 2 rooms at POP. We stayed there in 2005 and loved the resort and the theming. We will have 4 kids then, DD17, DS12, DD9 and DD3 1/2 mos. I think we will like having so much room to spread out and the two baths will be nice. 4 beds are another plus!!
 
Now I need to decide between--The Suite at All Star, 2 All Star Rooms or a Room at POR? Thoughts on those? I am thinking my kids will be 12, 9 and 7.

Help?

Oh and this may be our only trip, never been before and don't know if we will go back.

My kids are 12, 9, and 6 and POR did not feel cramped to us at all. I know it is definitely a matter of personal preference, but for us, we preferred to save a little money on the room and spend it elsewhere. (We planned it as a "once in a lifetime" trip also...now we're planning a trip in 2009!) We truly spent very little time in the actual room so it never felt too small. Yes, we are used to a queen at home, but I slept great in the bed at POR. Disney has a way of tiring you out! Anyway....not trying to contradict anyone who said it was small...just giving you an opinion from another family of 5 with kids about the same age as yours. Have a great trip whatever you decide!
 

We spent a week at POR last August with 5 in the room and had a terrific time. Ds 15 and ds 7 shared one double bed, and dd 13 used the trundle. She didn't have a problem with it, though she is relatively small (5'3" and 107 lbs). We really didn't spend much time in the room, though. I would definitely choose POR again if it meant that I could stay longer. If I had the extra money to spend (and could stay for the same length of time), I would choose two rooms at a value resort or the family suite just to give us the extra bathroom and a separate bed for each of the kids. If I really had extra money, I'd stay at CR again.
 
.....I'm also with Linda in that disney does not guarantee connecting rooms. We have requested and been granted connecting about 75% of the time.....maybe a little less. The stays we did not get connecting prompted us to buy DVC. There was enough inconveniences in not getting our requests met that it had negatively impacted our vacations and we knew we wanted something that we knew we could count on. ........

I agree. Not getting connecting rooms really does negatively impact ones vacation.
After we did not get our connecting rooms we stayed off property if all 6 of us were going to Disney. I was not going to have my family seperated again.
That experience also prompted me to write many letters to Disney asking for more options for larger families.
 
I was shocked that we had to fight so hard to get put in rooms that had just been fumigated for lice

Oh my word! I would have had the manager down there and let them know, ever so sweetly, that we would be in the lobby until they could properly accomodate us.

Bugs, lice....what next? Not Disney's fault, but so far each time I've heard about this instances Disney housekeeping has missed it and it was guests who found the problem, not housekeeping.

The most we've had in a room was 2 adults and 2 teens (girl and boy), so we had a rollaway (which is extra cost). It was comfortable in a CBR room, these rooms are larger than the other mods. But the funny thing was, it felt more comfortable at FQ - which I will never figure out since those rooms are smaller. Both times we had a corner room, but one opened from the right, the other the left - do not see how that could make a difference, but the FQ room did seem less cramped with the rollaway.

FQ, POR, CBR all have privacy curtains around the sink area. Do not know about CSR - have not stayed there. Also, we have been fortunate in getting connecting rooms all but once, and that was all adults. We even had connecting rooms for 6-8 rooms, two different trips. We had a line of rooms together, with each two rooms connecting.

Hope you find a Resort that will work comfortably for your budget and family!
 
Oh my word! I would have had the manager down there and let them know, ever so sweetly, that we would be in the lobby until they could properly accomodate us.

Bugs, lice....what next? Not Disney's fault, but so far each time I've heard about this instances Disney housekeeping has missed it and it was guests who found the problem, not housekeeping. ............
The rooms (that been pulled from inventory because of lice and still had wet carpets ) were the rooms taximomfor4 and her family ended up in because no other connecting rooms were available.

Here is her sad story from this thread:

http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=785797&page=1&pp=15

Here is the start of my trip report, for our 3/27--4/2 stay in 2 rooms at the ASMu resort. We oopsed, and drove the Ohio-Florida drive too quickly, so arrived in WDW at 2:30am, btw. I have a special needs dd 6, so CRO had transferred my original ressie to Special Services (whatever they are called). The rep there was very thorough about our needs...non-smoking, quiet location (facing AWAY from pools or parking lots), semi-close location to bus stop in case of episode, and a connecting door btw our rooms since its just me, dh, and 4 kids under 12 and dh would not even be there for several of the 6 nights. She froze our room assignment for us, only telling me the bldg and that the rooms ended in 2 and 3. OK....so we arrive 3/27 at 2:30am at ASMu.
Anyway, we went to McD's drivethru, watched a movie in our van, and did pre-checkin at 4am at ASMu. They confirmed our bldg, that the rooms ended in 2 & 3, and I double checked a higher floor and connecting door AGAIN (I had done so EVERY time I made a payment on my ressie, prior to arrival, and prior to canccelling my DTD SUITE I had also booked.) They said nope, its ground floor. But it DOES have the connecting door. We looked at which bldg, it was pretty close and faced away from the pool. So we bought 6 mugs for $72 (what a bargain) since we could easily refill a lot. We had to call at 3pm for the exact room numbers, though. No problem.
At 3pm, I called from a store in EPCOT, wanting to get something sent to me at the resort. Got the room numbers (which DID end in 2 & 3, of course). Asked again if someone made SURE there was the connecting door. OF COURSE THERE IS! At 8pm, arrived at the hotel, filled our mugs, went to our Non Smoking rooms. First room ok, second room REEKS of TONS of smoke. Asthma. No way. Then we notice NO connecting door. WHAT?! With my dd's care needs, it is ESSENTIAL to have access all night, while still having access to my preschooler and toddler! We call front desk. After 30 minutes of no answer, we load up the kids (who had been up sionce 2:30am now!) and walk to the lobby. I stand (and then SIT) in the unmoving Guest Svcs line, while DH stands in the slow-moving checkin line. The kids fall asleep on the bench. Finally, DH gets to a CM who insists that we NEVER requested a connecting door. WHAT?!!!!????!!!! I run over there, re-tell the tale, etc. He looks at our family and says that with our 6 people, 4 being young kids, we are pretty much stuck since we have to have a connecting door but they are at 100% capacity and won't have one for us. We almost started back to Ohio that night!
He called around, they finally found us connecting rooms in the Country Fair bldg. They were apparently available still because the carpets were soaked -- they had just shampooed them! One room had no remote control, a broken clothesline, and a running bathtub (VERY annoying in the night!!) But we had the connecting door so I had access to all the children while DH was gone! .............

I KNOW, since the lobby CM was so kind to point it out, that Connecting Doors is "ONLY" a request. But with the several months of dealing with Special Services about the disability needs (of which quiet but not excessive trekking was a part), getting these"perfect" rooms promised, WITH connecting doors which I was told are MORE than a request when 2 or less adults are part of the large party, and then having it turn into THIS mess was very disheartening. Especially when the ressie said "Guaranteed Connecting ROoms for Families." I had to convince my dh to try a WDW vacation as it was. He was decidedly UNIMPRESSED.

I got a really nice CM on the phone with CRO (about my upcoming trip with stepmom), started to vent to him ( he was WONDERFUL at defusing my anger, BTW). He gave me an email addy for Guest communications, which I have emailed in detail. I know that responses are slow or nonexistant, but I really need them to do SOMETHING to make my husband believe they want to make this all right!

Thanks for listening, all! Any questions, lmk!
Beth
 
The best option would probably be two rooms at the All Stars or at Pop (which, IMHO, is nicer). Not only would that be cheaper if you didn't book preferred rooms, but you would have the most space (even more than a family suite) of the three options. I think your kids might be too old for the one POR room and that room would be very tight for 5 people. Not only might the trundle bed be too small, but you only have one bathroom compared to the two bathrooms in the options at the values. With the two value rooms, you get 4 real beds (all doubles) instead of two doubles and a tiny trundle at POR or one queen and 3 or 4 sofa beds (I don't care how nice sofa beds are, they still aren't real beds) at an All Star family suite. If you request adjoining rooms you almost always get it (especially if it means splitting up the parents) and that is the only risk you run booking two rooms.

2 value rooms are the exact same square footage as the family suite. BUT the kitchenette takes up a bit of that valuable space.
AND there is the risk of not getting adjoining rooms...
 
Thank you for posting the TR.

This poor woman - what a shame they had to go through such nonsense. Of course she would expect Special Needs to have taken care that the requests would be met! My heart goes out to them. Unfortunately, we live and learn when it comes to Disney resort requests - when the requests are very important, for medical reasons etc.

Some hints from old timers might have helped: be at the Resort at 3 pm to make the call and ask to see the room before accepting it to be sure it met all the requirements. Have the phone number of Special Needs handy, with the name of a supervisor.

In Feb we spent the night at POP and were at the front desk at BW at 8 am, working with the CM and manager to be sure the room would work with severe asthma and MS needs.

Learned years ago to ask the CM to take us to the room location - one room was still occupied, but he found an emtpy one which turned out to be perfect! Of course, it was not the room we were assigned. They really did try to meet the requests, but what they perceived to be the best room was not even close. So, it was not for lack of trying this time, but simply interpretation.

Some CM's are more patient and understanding than others - just human nature. Most of the time we have been lucky, but when not, try to remain positive and friendly.
 
Wow ! I commend you Melsmice for making that work ! :thumbsup2 :worship:
I might do it for a 2 or 3 nights top. But for a week stay, we'd be miserable with 3 teens and dh and I in one room at POR---and that's exactly what I have (two teen girls and one teen boy). Sure shows how everyone is different and has different vacation needs/preferences.
It could be the way we "do Disney" also. We are DVC owners & AP holders so we are there quite a bit. Most days are spent at the pool & evenings at the parks.

One or 2 kids will head up to the room around 4 or 5 p.m. to get showered & the rest will follow little by little, so there's not a huge bathroom issue for us.

If we are heading out early in the morning, the girls will shower in the evening.
 
It could be the way we "do Disney" also. We are DVC owners & AP holders so we are there quite a bit. Most days are spent at the pool & evenings at the parks.
Melsmice,
I'm a DVC Member as well.....and we also go often. I was there in 2006: Feb, Aug, Oct, Dec
in 2007 : Feb, will be in Aug and Sept as well....and looking at early Dec too (that's not yet booked though).

I don't know....I still give u credit. We like to spread out a bit more and hate waiting to share the bathroom/shower. We are doing a disney cruise in Sept as well and like the idea of the split bathroom. So two people can be doing their "thing" at the same time.
 
Melsmice,
I'm a DVC Member as well.....and we also go often. I was there in 2006: Feb, Aug, Oct, Dec
in 2007 : Feb, will be in Aug and Sept as well....and looking at early Dec too (that's not yet booked though).

I don't know....I still give u credit. We like to spread out a bit more and hate waiting to share the bathroom/shower. We are doing a disney cruise in Sept as well and like the idea of the split bathroom. So two people can be doing their "thing" at the same time.
After seeing how often you're there & where you travel from I don't feel so bad about how often we go. We are from the Buffalo, NY area, so travel far also. I'd love to get more points right now - have all the info right in front of me actually!!!!!

We were there this past Feb., April & going in October. Depending on schedules (& funds) may be there next Feb., March & April - keeping my fingers crossed that we're lucky enough to go that much!!! (who knows - maybe we'll win the lottery!!)

Sorry to hijack, OP! :)
 
Most comfortable stay was at a 2 bed OKW. Favorite resort value wise was POR, 1 room, cosy but great value. we also have stayed 2 rooms at POFQ which cost more but was lovely, and 2 rooms at CBR costly but lovely. Stayed 2 rooms at POP last year and missed the wonderful landscaping and theming of POR. Didnt like the small rooms even though we had 2 bathrooms.
 
In 2005 we stayed at POR and fell head over heels for it. It worked out great because the kids were small. They were 8, almost 7, and and almost 3 at the time. Dh and I cannot share a double bed without someone being pushed off, so I slept with our daughter, dh had the youngest son, and middle son happily slept on the trundle. Not ideal, but it worked at the time.

Our next trip in 2007 they will be 11, almost 10, and almost 6 (I mention the "almost" because my boys both have birthdays within two weeks of our trip, it makes a difference at this age). All five of us squished into a small room with two double beds and a small trundle with one bathroom will not be comfortable. We're opting for two rooms at Pop instead. We will request (and beg and plead, ha ha) for connecting rooms but have the back up plan of boys in one room, girls in the other if we don't get it. I'm not crazy about splitting up the family, but I am even less crazy about sharing a double bed with one of the kids, or worse, with my very tall husband. :laughing: It just would not work!

I'd go deluxe if we had the money, but that's not happening unless we hit the lotto. I'm excited about Pop. It'll be fun!
 
How can we settle the "guaranteed" connecting rooms issue? We are booked in two rooms at ASMo in October and the CM at reservations told me we indeed WERE guaranteed connecting rooms since we are a family - me, DW, DD and DS. I specifically asked her if she was sure, and told her I'd always been told there were no guarantees of connecting rooms. She assured me it was a guarantee. :confused3 :confused3 :confused3
 
I was also told that they would guarantee connecting rooms if it was for a single family. We ended up booking the Family Suite at All-Stars this time and we shall see how it goes! I picked it because we have stayed at POR before and while it was nice, it was WAY too cramped for a family of 5. Hubby and I also don't like sharing a Double bed - we have a King at home. I am concerned that the kids will sleep on sofa beds this time but it seemed to make sense for our situation.
 
I fell in love with POR! We went for what we thought would be our first and maybe only trip to WDW too. We had to decide on staying offsite with car or on site without. I am so happy that we decided to stay on site and at POR.

Most magical moment: We arrived late on first day and took the boats to Downtown Disney. WOW!!!

Trundle bed: Not big... but heck, I could sleep on it if I had to and I'm 5'7.

Atmosphere: Beautiful and I never thought twice about the cost!

Would I return?: In a heartbeat! We are actually returning this January (so much for the once in a lifetime trip!!!!). But since we are taking my mom and sister with us, we need 2 rooms wherever we are. So we are going to try a different resort "this time", since it may be our only chance to do so. I am not sure we'll ever be able to afford the Deluxes.

Even though I started out with a tight budget, wished for a Value... I was thrilled that we did it the way we did. Our stay was worth every penny and all 5 of us were comfortable!
 
We did 2 connecting rooms at POP last December and it worked great. Our 3 kids (ages 9,7 and 4 at the time) had one room with 2 beds and we had the connector with the King. It was great to have 2 toilets, showers and sinks and when they went to bed at night we could stay up watching tv in our room. It was really nice to have our own space.

Allyson
 
Dragonfly says :Trundle bed: Not big... but heck, I could sleep on it if I had to and I'm 5'7.
Wow....it's been several years since I've stayed at POR, but I don't recall the trundle being anywhere near imaginably comfortable for an adult ? Have they changed since '99 I wonder ?

From the allears site :
The Trundle Bed is intended to accommodate children under 9; or persons under 5 feet tall. They are narrower than a conventional bed.

Here's a pic of the trundle : http://www.allearsnet.com/acc/dxl24.jpg compared to the regular bed : http://www.allearsnet.com/acc/dxl22.jpg
 



New Posts



Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom