We are going to make a family suite for our family of 5 (8, 15, and 17 ) out of two adjoining cat 9s.
We have had the 2 connecting verandahs in the past and it worked out well, but to be cost effective we are going with the porthole.
We also tried the cat 11s last cruise and it wasnt so much claustrophobic , but disorienting. No way to differentiate betweed day and night, that bothered us.
If we were smaller I would go for the cat 4, but I think the affordable happy medium here for us is the two 9s.
sleeps up to 8 2 large portholes 4 sinks 2 toiloits, 2 showers, double the closet and drawer space, I think it will work.
Im sure the verandah makes for some nice experiences though. Just weigh it out carefully and do what makes you feel happiest.
Felicia