Fairfield, Ramada Maingate or Carousel Inn?

[Albertan mom]

If you were choosing from these 3 which would you pick?

Ramada Maingate
Carousel Inn
Fairfield Inn
Tropicana

Any goods/bads about each of them?

Thanks!

 

[WTFetus]

Never stayed at Carousel, but I prefer Fairfield over the Ramada. It's a little bit farther (still very walkable to the gates), but the stay was comfier. Better beds and cleaner bathrooms are more important to me than a free breakfast (very limited with just bagels and fruits). My stay at Ramada wasn't very great; stuffy rooms and an extremely loud room fan.

 

[Albertan mom]

OK thanks.
When did you stay there?
Was it before or after the renos?

 

[WTFetus]

OK thanks.
When did you stay there?
Was it before or after the renos?

Think it was during/after? For Ramada right?

Fairfield: June 2012. March 2014.
Ramada: June 2013

 

[mich311e]

We have only ever stayed at the Carousel and we loved it so much we never stray. It's so close to the crosswalk to enter the parks!

 

[Jkpark]

The room with free breakfast (continental) at Carousel has views of parks which my kids love.

 

[sassydisneymomma]

We stayed at the Carousel last month... we were there 6 nights.... the service was awful, maid service was terrible, they never swept the room, gave us fresh towels once, even though the dirty ones were on the floor, we asked for rooms on the elevator side... they said we'd get them, but we didn't and had to take strollers up and down stairs every.single.day... valet scratched my new suv.... I am a bit bitter about it since I am still trying to get them to fix the scratches in my one year old suv! And the beds... they old beds were much comfier than these "upgraded" ones. I was disappointed.

 

[Albertan mom]

I booked at the Tropicana, as they had a great special!
Hopefully it is ok!
Thanks all!