Would they honestly close the attraction to all but
DVC anyway? It seems like they would let anyone on if the ride was running and the line didn't have very many people in it. I understand your frustration but we really didn't have any kind of fight for this perk...they just gave it to us (as well as the AP holders). I guess my attitude is that everyone goes to WDW for one thing, to have fun...and I try to not sweat the small stuff.