I love sandwiches and had been waiting to try this place after hearing all the good reviews. I was in Disney Springs in late May and we went there and I was unimpressed. I had a roast beef and cheese sandwich. It was very small, with no toppings such as lettuce or tomato, and just a hint of the horseradish sauce. The side of mac and cheese was fine, nothing terrible or spectacular. Its a crowded place by the CMs did a good job of cleaning tables as people left.
I was really hoping for more. After we ate, I went inside the Wolfgang Puck express nearby to grab a cup of ice water and was impressed by their menu. Will probably try that over Earl of Sandwich. It was a lot less crowded too.
ETA: To be fair, DW got a wrap at Earl of Sandwich which she said was good. It looked good and was bigger than my sandwich.