I think you’d lose the initial deposit for one or both brokers.
I know Davids DVCrequest.com will refund the deposit if the reservation cannot be secured to your satisfaction. Perhaps other brokers have a non-refundable deposit policy, but David does refund the deposit on unavailable reservations. If other brokers do NOT refund the deposit for reservations they cannot fill perhaps that is a good reason not to deal with them. I would
NOT suggest placing a deposit with multiple brokers (since they could all come in with the reservation requested) and
NOT with any broker who does not refund unfulfilled reservations. But to be clear, DVCrequest.com
does refund deposits on reservations they are unable to secure.
Potential renters can also seek reservations from
DVC Members offering to make reservations on the DIS
DVC Rent/Trade Board. I am not aware of any member offering to rent who asks for a deposit before checking availability. Just another option.
From DVCrequest.com :
"
Why We Collect a $112.00 Part Payment
Disney Vacation Club Resorts often sell out months in advance. If one of your requested resort/room combinations is available, we don't want to lose the availability or waste your valuable time with additional dialogue. By having your part payment on hand, we can immediately take the steps necessary to secure your reservation. Of course, if your requested resort/room combinations are not available, in the order you have selected, we'll give you the opportunity to select a different resort/room combination that might be available, or
we will immediately refund your part payment. It's all about choice. Yours."
and -
"If your request
can not be fulfilled:
- You will be given the opportunity to book available rooms/resorts.
- If they are not satisfactory to you, your $112.00 partial payment is refunded."