I think it's a lot of personal preferences.
I just got my welcome home from Disney at Beach Club Villas. When I was looking I looked through the resale lists first. There were a lot of contracts available with high unused points available. The Point savings seemed better, but I wanted the benefits of financing which can be difficult without going through Disney. When I decided to just go with Disney, they surprised me and gave me one of the last points at BCV with a December renewal month. Even though it's later in the year they bought back my 200 points for $10/pt, and I'll get 200 points again in December 2003. To me, it was almost as if finding a resale with all it's points intact and then some.
Now my contract worked out at $74/pt, I was able to finance on my terms, ( and payoff with my yearly bonus later), and no closing points.
Most of the resales are going for $70 - $72. I noticed additional closing costs are approx $500 and possible reimbursement of annual dues if the sellers had left points for you could easily have pushed the selling price up to $76 - $78 a point.
For me the process took about a week, I didn't have to face the fear Disney would take option of first refusal, and I knew who I was dealing with.
In the end, you'll be like any other
DVC Member, so get a good estimate on what fits your pocket book, and shop around.