We have our faves. So we also have those that we don't care for. To be polite about it, it's good that
DVC has such diversity in its resort offerings. Different people like different things. We've stayed at all WDW DVC properties, and would not choose to return to:
1. AKV (both buildings) - too far away from just about everything, don't love its feel or look, and IMO, the dining is severely overrated. Well, maybe not Sanaa.
2. Poly - crowded. Crowded. Crowded. Oh, and the 70's dark wood vibe just isn't for us. 'Ohana is not a favorite. Don't even get me started on the tower...
3. RIV - don't like the kitchen layouts of the more recent DVC's. Space savers (so $ saver for Disney perhaps?) with the kitchen "sideways" against a wall. Not our style. And we don't like high-rises. Towers save on space needed, land needed, etc. So again, cheaper for Disney. Some people like them, not us. And IMO, Topolino's has seriously declined in quality (both breakfast and dinner) since it first opened.
4. Copper Creek - while we adore BRV, CC comes up way short. Smaller rooms, sideways kitchens, sort of like "hey, let's jam some DVC rooms in what was an already awesome resort!"
5. BLT - Just so much we don't love. It does have that location, however, and would concede to stay there just for that. Oh, and the monorail!
These are just my/our feelings (in our household). People may not agree, and that's fine with me. OKW and the BWV are amongst our faves, but others don't love them. BCV aren't loved by all, and above, a legitimate concern about its proximity to the parks is brought up. We love the BCV. So again, different strokes...
More than ever, we are resort people and not park commandos! So being able to cook at our place, enjoy amenities, walk aplenty, and have a nice pool are tops on our list. It's been an evolution as our kids are in their mid and late 20's now.