I'm just curious. We have made requests in the past and it just seems hit or miss, It also seems it takes so much longer to get your room because they do seem to make an effort to meet guest requests. We stayed at the Poly in June and just requested a balcony, we arrived at 7:30am and our room was ready with a balcony. I had been debating about making a room request for our Oct trip to the Poly and I think I will again go very basic, "balcony" and just be surprised by what building.
Non-smoking is as picky as we get.
My DH and I always stay at the Mods, preferably POFQ, and we request second floor. Our experience is that the first floor rooms tend to be a bit musty, where as the second floors are not. So far we have not had a problem with making requests. Knock on wood, we have made the same request for our up coming Feb '08 trip.