Can't agree with even half of it. I'm not a fan of the value resorts, and personally wouldn't stay in them, but have stayed in both Pop and ASSp and would recommend Sports over Pop. I wouldn't take AoA out of the value category even though the price is even with a moderate since if you aren't getting a suite, the rooms are the same level as the other value resorts but you pay more.
Of the moderates, I've stayed at all except POFQ, did walk over and have been to the lobby and food court. I wouldn't recommend CSR, I'd say CBR is better. I just got back a couple of weeks ago from CSR and it just didn't feel as comfy to me as POR and CBR and I paid more for it. The only reason I even stayed there is I was doing a split stay and am on a mission to stay at all the resorts at least once. It is the only moderate I wouldn't repeat unless the price was just so low that wouldn't make sense not to.
I'd go with any of the Epcot deluxe resorts as a favorite deluxe hands down, with YC being my #1. I enjoyed AKV, we had a Savannah view one bedroom, it was big and it was comfy and I would stay there on a split stay again, but it wouldn't be my #1.
I've stayed at OKW, not SSS yet and I agree it is a fair distance from the parks but if I had to choose between that and off site, OKW would win every time.
I've stayed at Swan and loved it and would stay there over any of the MK deluxe resorts in a heartbeat. Especially if I had points, yes you have to pay the resort fee and the parking, but if you have points to spend you are getting an Epcot resort for around $50/night, it's a no brainer. No it isn't in your face Disney but that might actually make it more attractive.
Have to disagree with GF, if I were going to stay at a MK resort, that would probably be my #1 choice. I've stayed at GF, Poly and CR, not WL yet and love GF. You can get it for much less that $600 a night if you are just diligent in looking for discounts.
I'm not a big fan of renting points, I've done it (that was my OKW visit) and just don't like the restrictions. I rarely know any further in advance than 3 months that I'm going, I don't like not having the option of cancelling and if I'm staying in a
DVC I'd rather do it through Disney and get the resort benefits of daily mousekeeping, coffee every day, etc.