Do kids deserve a second chance? Your opinion on zero tolerance policies.

wgeo

DIS Veteran
Joined
May 2, 2011
Messages
2,364
My high school aged children came home from marching band practice last night and asked if I had heard anything about what happened to one of the drum majors. They said a lot of rumors were circulating through the kids but the only thing known for sure is that the drum major was removed from the band. Our marching program is large and rather intense. The teachers are very clear that they have a zero tolerance policy for drinking/drugs/smoking and for breaking social media rules. They have heard of children beig kicked out for vaping at the end of last year.

So what's your opinion? If a kid does something stupid once (say for example on social media) is it ok to take away an honor that's he has worked so hard for? Or should he get a second chance?

I mainly lean toward the teachers making the right call. They are very clear on their policy and they have a large program and need to teach the kids respect and responsiblity. But there is a little part of me inside where my heart breaks for this kid. Cuz he's still just a kid and he screwed up, and it had really big consequences.
 
I graduated from an alternative school that gave kids a second chance and we also had a zero tolerance policy, but only for fighting or drugs. It definitely worked for keeping fighting to a minimum. I feel like some offenses are not as big as others and the punishment should fit the crime. Bullying on campus and online, and drugs and alcohol on campus are hard nos, but smoking or posting questionable photos of yourself online shouldn't get a kid expelled, in my opinion.
 
My high school aged children came home from marching band practice last night and asked if I had heard anything about what happened to one of the drum majors. They said a lot of rumors were circulating through the kids but the only thing known for sure is that the drum major was removed from the band. Our marching program is large and rather intense. The teachers are very clear that they have a zero tolerance policy for drinking/drugs/smoking and for breaking social media rules. They have heard of children beig kicked out for vaping at the end of last year.

So what's your opinion? If a kid does something stupid once (say for example on social media) is it ok to take away an honor that's he has worked so hard for? Or should he get a second chance?

I mainly lean toward the teachers making the right call. They are very clear on their policy and they have a large program and need to teach the kids respect and responsiblity. But there is a little part of me inside where my heart breaks for this kid. Cuz he's still just a kid and he screwed up, and it had really big consequences.
While I don't think zero tolerance policies should always be used (depends on the circumstances), presumably the policy was in place and the kids agreed to it. Therefore, this is on the kid. It's no different than a parent saying "if you don't clean you're room, we're not going to the park". You HAVE to follow through with consequences once you've named them. Keep in mind while this drum major will suffer, it's also a lesson to the other band members that there's no special treatment.

I'm not familiar with band, but isn't a drum major one of the "leaders"? Presumably they've been with the band for a number of years and know what the rules are?
 
I don't believe in blanket zero tolerance policies. - That doesn't mean I think a harsh punishment is never appropriate, but just that things with kids should be handled on a case-by-case basis.

I agree and hope that behind the scenes they look at all circumstances. I have confidence in the teachers and imagine that whatever the drum major did, it must have been pretty serious.
 
I graduated from an alternative school that gave kids a second chance and we also had a zero tolerance policy, but only for fighting or drugs. It definitely worked for keeping fighting to a minimum. I feel like some offenses are not as big as others and the punishment should fit the crime. Bullying on campus and online, and drugs and alcohol on campus are hard nos, but smoking or posting questionable photos of yourself online shouldn't get a kid expelled, in my opinion.

Yeah, the sympathetic part of me says - can't you just take away his leadership responsibilites and still let him stay in the band? But I don't know exactly what he did, so I really can't make a fair assessment.
 
We have zero tolerance policies and I'm fine with it, especially at the high school level. Those kids are more than old enough to be able to fully understand the rules and potential consequences.
While I don't think zero tolerance policies should always be used (depends on the circumstances), presumably the policy was in place and the kids agreed to it. Therefore, this is on the kid. It's no different than a parent saying "if you don't clean you're room, we're not going to the park". You HAVE to follow through with consequences once you've named them. Keep in mind while this drum major will suffer, it's also a lesson to the other band members that there's no special treatment.

I'm not familiar with band, but isn't a drum major one of the "leaders"? Presumably they've been with the band for a number of years and know what the rules are?

Yes to both of you - he was a senior and they are incredibly clear on their policies from the very first day of freshman band camp. So he was aware. And yes, he worked very hard to be drum major and has spent an incredible number of hours involved in the band to get this leadership position. So there's no way that he was unaware of the rules. Perhaps he did really think that he would be afforded special treatment? Or more likely, he just imagined he wouldn't get caught.

I would think it sends a very very clear message to the rest of the students.
 
I don’t always agree with it.

For example, my daughter was harassed and kicked by a boy. She retaliated and they both received the same punishment. Yes she broke the rules, but she left with no choice.

However, if you blatantly disregard the rules, then you get no sympathy.
 
While I don't think zero tolerance policies should always be used (depends on the circumstances), presumably the policy was in place and the kids agreed to it. Therefore, this is on the kid. It's no different than a parent saying "if you don't clean you're room, we're not going to the park". You HAVE to follow through with consequences once you've named them. Keep in mind while this drum major will suffer, it's also a lesson to the other band members that there's no special treatment.

I'm not familiar with band, but isn't a drum major one of the "leaders"? Presumably they've been with the band for a number of years and know what the rules are?
I agree 100% with the bolded, which is why it’s so extremely important that the list of violations is reasonable, whatever they may be. If the list gets too long or too subjective it becomes rife for challenge and compromises will eventually be made, rendering the entire thing toothless.
Yes to both of you - he was a senior and they are incredibly clear on their policies from the very first day of freshman band camp. So he was aware. And yes, he worked very hard to be drum major and has spent an incredible number of hours involved in the band to get this leadership position. So there's no way that he was unaware of the rules. Perhaps he did really think that he would be afforded special treatment? Or more likely, he just imagined he wouldn't get caught.

I would think it sends a very very clear message to the rest of the students.
From your previous post I’m unclear on what your opinion is. Given what you’ve said here, does this kid sound like he deserves another chance to you?
 
From your previous post I’m unclear on what your opinion is. Given what you’ve said here, does this kid sound like he deserves another chance to you?

I'm actually pretty conflicted. I don't know what he did, which of course would help to form a solid opinion. But overall I side with the teachers and have to assume that they made the right call. Still feel bad for the kid though. Tough lesson to learn, and to have his entire senior year plans thrown out the window. I mean the kid practically lived in the band room and now that's gone. But then again - of any kid, he really should have known this could happen. LOL - see I am conflicted!
 
I think zero-tolerance policies have their place, but all punishments have to fit the crime and must also fit all other crimes. What I mean by that is that if some offense is worse than another offense, then the punishment for the first offense should be worse than for the second offense. The worst offenses involve harming other people. The strongest punishments should be reserved for those offenses and shouldn't be used for any other offenses. Otherwise, we're teaching children to have no sense of perspective in life. So issue suspensions and expulsions for fighting, definitely. But don't have the same penalties for cutting school, or for vaping, or for cussing.
 
Zero tolerance is fine. And there should be a process to appeal for reinstatement. This way the offending party can have the opportunity to prove remorse.

I feel like if there is a process for appeal then it actually isn't a zero tolerance policy. By definition, zero tolerance means no appeal, no case by case consideration. I do like the idea of a kid being able to prove remorse, so perhaps I'd be more comfortable with a "very strict rules and consequences" policy instead of "zero tolerance". But I feel like I'm splitting hairs here.
 
I don’t have as big an issue zero tolerance as I do with it when not enforced across the board.

Just an example, when ods was in high school all sports and activities were supposed to have a zero tolerance drug and alcohol policy. Two football players who were not “Star” players got caught smoking pot. They were kicked off the team. Fine. Then one of the running backs (and a very good one) went to class high! It was a Monday. He was suspended Tuesday and Wednesday, and was in the game Friday night. Their playing ability shouldn’t have had anything to do with it but it honestly did.
 
I feel like if there is a process for appeal then it actually isn't a zero tolerance policy. By definition, zero tolerance means no appeal, no case by case consideration. I do like the idea of a kid being able to prove remorse, so perhaps I'd be more comfortable with a "very strict rules and consequences" policy instead of "zero tolerance". But I feel like I'm splitting hairs here.
:confused3In cases like this, what kid wouldn’t be remorseful - for getting caught and for the consequences he’s now facing. I don’t think that’s very meaningful and in some ways can actually be counter-productive to behaviour modification.

I know I’m sounding draconian here but I do think the whole thing hinges on what exactly the rules are. I’m not for “judicial over-reach” on any level or for our lives being micro-managed but I do have a great respect for authority and conformity to rules as the foundation of a civil society.
 
I feel like if there is a process for appeal then it actually isn't a zero tolerance policy. By definition, zero tolerance means no appeal, no case by case consideration. I do like the idea of a kid being able to prove remorse, so perhaps I'd be more comfortable with a "very strict rules and consequences" policy instead of "zero tolerance". But I feel like I'm splitting hairs here.
I mean zero tolerance as in, you mess up, you get booted out. If you want back in there should be a process you can go through to prove remorse. If you don't bother to go through the steps or don't fulfill the steps then you stay out.
 
:confused3In cases like this, what kid wouldn’t be remorseful - for getting caught and for the consequences he’s now facing. I don’t think that’s very meaningful and in some ways can actually be counter-productive to behaviour modification.

I know I’m sounding draconian here but I do think the whole thing hinges on what exactly the rules are. I’m not for “judicial over-reach” on any level or for our lives being micro-managed but I do have a great respect for authority and conformity to rules as the foundation of a civil society.

Yes, most are remorseful after they are caught. But that only happens, after they are caught...lol.

I too am generally a rule follower and you know, actions have consequences. The sooner a person catches on to that the better. A senior in high school is very close to going on to college or joining the workforce (or a combination of both) and there are plenty of rules associated with those things as well.
 
I believe in facing the consequences of your actions.
If one works hard to accomplish something then that includes following the rules set.
I also believe that one single incident shouldn't always determine your forever fate, so like a pp said there should be a process to redeem yourself.
If you don't get in trouble for the rest of the school year then you are free to audition or try out for the activity next year.
It also depends on what the student did, stupid mistakes are different than breaking laws.
 
I feel like if there is a process for appeal then it actually isn't a zero tolerance policy. By definition, zero tolerance means no appeal, no case by case consideration. I do like the idea of a kid being able to prove remorse, so perhaps I'd be more comfortable with a "very strict rules and consequences" policy instead of "zero tolerance". But I feel like I'm splitting hairs here.
To me, an appeal would be like trying to prove whatever the act was wasn't done by the student in question. DS almost got called to the office last year for vaping on school property. The security cameras showed a tall blond boy vaping and TPTB thought it was DS. One of the security guards who knows DS (the guard's DD plays on our DD's soccer team) says "there's no way" and they looked closer and identified someone else. If DS would have been punished for something he didn't do, he should be able to appeal.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom