wgeo
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- May 2, 2011
- Messages
- 2,364
My high school aged children came home from marching band practice last night and asked if I had heard anything about what happened to one of the drum majors. They said a lot of rumors were circulating through the kids but the only thing known for sure is that the drum major was removed from the band. Our marching program is large and rather intense. The teachers are very clear that they have a zero tolerance policy for drinking/drugs/smoking and for breaking social media rules. They have heard of children beig kicked out for vaping at the end of last year.
So what's your opinion? If a kid does something stupid once (say for example on social media) is it ok to take away an honor that's he has worked so hard for? Or should he get a second chance?
I mainly lean toward the teachers making the right call. They are very clear on their policy and they have a large program and need to teach the kids respect and responsiblity. But there is a little part of me inside where my heart breaks for this kid. Cuz he's still just a kid and he screwed up, and it had really big consequences.
So what's your opinion? If a kid does something stupid once (say for example on social media) is it ok to take away an honor that's he has worked so hard for? Or should he get a second chance?
I mainly lean toward the teachers making the right call. They are very clear on their policy and they have a large program and need to teach the kids respect and responsiblity. But there is a little part of me inside where my heart breaks for this kid. Cuz he's still just a kid and he screwed up, and it had really big consequences.
In cases like this, what kid wouldn’t be remorseful - for getting caught and for the consequences he’s now facing. I don’t think that’s very meaningful and in some ways can actually be counter-productive to behaviour modification.