Do I have a claim for Unemployment?

They gave us very little warning about this, we were told that this was happening in early March, and the building is slated for closure on July 1st. My last day is going to be May 3rd.
That is a whole lot of warning! People have showed up to work here only to find the place shut down overnight- or were alerted in the email that night not to come to work because the restaurant is closed as of the morning. So they gave plenty of warning to you.
 
I don't think there's anything you can do, except present any information the state asks for as quickly as you can.

Is it normal for an employer to appeal a former employee being granted benefits? Is this just part of the system?
 

In Washington state employers are supposed to put in all exit paperwork to unemployment. A large employer is going to follow unemployment law perfectly. If something is not worded correctly on the unemployment paperwork the company will appeal. This is normal. Fill out the paper work sent on a timely manor. Tell l the judge exactly what happened. Most likely your former employer and you will a have the same story. The judge will decide how the law is applied to you. In Washington state the repayment of unemployment benefits that should not have been received is a zero to low interist loan. (if it's clearly fraud that is different). I would recommend to continue to file and if possible put the money you get aside in a savings account. That way you have it if you need to pay it back and if you need a bit to pay bills in the mean time you have it. Good Luck!
 
Well, I guess I'd better not withdraw anything more until it gets adjudicated, incase they decide against me and make me repay them.
I mentioned it upthread some time back, but it probably wouldn't hurt to take a look at the regulations in your state regarding constructive discharge, which is exactly what your circumstance seems to my mind.
 
I mentioned it upthread some time back, but it probably wouldn't hurt to take a look at the regulations in your state regarding constructive discharge, which is exactly what your circumstance seems to my mind.

I will look into this for the hearing. Thank you for letting me know.
 
An update: Still waiting on a date for the hearing, but I've seen the Appeal letter from my former employer. They claim the reason I resigned is because I was dissatisfied with the hours I was offered but still continued to work the same hours. That makes no sense to me, but they claim to have a witness to corroborate this.

But I also have a witness that will confirm my side of the claim, that the reason I resigned was because the building had closed and the distance to the new building was unreasonable, and he said he'd be willing to affirm this to the judge if necessary.

Still unsure about how this will all play out though. Really wish they would just schedule a date already so I can get this over with, however it goes down.
 
An update: Still waiting on a date for the hearing, but I've seen the Appeal letter from my former employer. They claim the reason I resigned is because I was dissatisfied with the hours I was offered but still continued to work the same hours. That makes no sense to me, but they claim to have a witness to corroborate this.

But I also have a witness that will confirm my side of the claim, that the reason I resigned was because the building had closed and the distance to the new building was unreasonable, and he said he'd be willing to affirm this to the judge if necessary.

Still unsure about how this will all play out though. Really wish they would just schedule a date already so I can get this over with, however it goes down.
It's so tough. I was denied unemployment and had to appeal during Covid even though I could easily explain why it was initially denied because some low level employee misunderstood the classification of my job. My company wasn't even opposing it. It took almost a year to get a hearing and I finally got all my back pay after literally a five minute hearing with someone who had some critical skills and wasn't just trying to process an unmanageable amount of applications. It was the scariest time of my life and I don't understand how they can expect people to last that long waiting for benefits they are entitled to receive.

ETA: It also screwed me up on taxes because what should have been split between two tax years were paid out in one which wasn't really fair either.
 
Last edited:
It's so tough. I was denied unemployment and had to appeal during Covid even though I could easily explain why it was initially denied because some low level employee misunderstood the classification of my job. My company wasn't even opposing it. It took almost a year to get a hearing and I finally got all my back pay after literally a five minute hearing with someone who had some critical skills and wasn't just trying to process an unmanageable amount of applications. It was the scariest time of my life and I don't understand how they can expect people to last that long waiting for benefits they are entitled to receive.

I just don't know what to think of this anymore. I don't know if they're serious about this and have information to dispute my claim, or if they're just throwing darts at the wall to try and save money.

Even though I now have a witness supporting my claim, I don't know if that will matter in the end.
 
I just don't know what to think of this anymore. I don't know if they're serious about this and have information to dispute my claim, or if they're just throwing darts at the wall to try and save money.

Even though I now have a witness supporting my claim, I don't know if that will matter in the end.
They expect you to give up. Don't. You are entitled to these benefits even if you get a job before the hearing. You have a witness. They just don't expect you to hang in there. I know it doesn't help financially in the moment, but I think this can come out in your favor if you stick it out.
 
They expect you to give up. Don't. You are entitled to these benefits even if you get a job before the hearing. You have a witness. They just don't expect you to hang in there. I know it doesn't help financially in the moment, but I think this can come out in your favor if you stick it out.

That's what I'm going to do, win or lose, but I'll keep hoping for the best. At least I have another interview today with Goodwill. It's frustrating getting ghosted after interviews though; this is my 5th one.
 
Sorry you're going through this AND it's helpful to hear others are in similar boat. I've never requested unemployment though there have been a couple of times it should've been available. I should have access now - but something weird is going on and it's so hard to figure out, nail down, etc.
 
I just don't know what to think of this anymore. I don't know if they're serious about this and have information to dispute my claim, or if they're just throwing darts at the wall to try and save money.

Even though I now have a witness supporting my claim, I don't know if that will matter in the end.
I've seen these actually wind up in court when the bureaucratic process gets it wrong. Judges typically have little trouble sussing out which side deserves justice, be it the employer or the employee. While states do have different particulars of law about many things, overall legal standards tend to be fairly similar, so I would expect constructive discharge to be in play. I'm not an attorney, but it seems painfully clear from the facts you've laid out from the beginning that is what your situation boils down to. If that is the case I do believe you will prevail, hopefully without actually needing to proceed to a legal challenge in a courtroom. It's simply not credible on its face to accept that the move is entirely irrelevant in the situation. That's a big hurdle your employer will have a heck of a time persuading anyone to believe, whether it's a bureaucrat or a judge.

Best of luck.
 
That's the other thing that worries me: Even if their appeal is denied, what's to stop them from doing a Level 2 appeal and going directly to the Board? I can't afford a lawyer so at that point I don't know if I can continue to fight it.

We'll see, I guess.
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top