Hoping to get some opinions from people who've stayed in both Family Suites and DVC accommodations!
We're booked in a Cars Suite at Art of Animation for early October — 4 adults (my wife and I, plus her parents) and 2 kids (ages 4 and almost 3). Our plan is to put the kids in the closed-door bedroom so the adults can have some downtime after bedtime. That said, the bedroom only has a queen, so depending on how the nights go, my wife may end up in there with them. That would leave grandpa and grandma on the Murphy table bed and me on the pull-out couch. Not ideal, but workable.
We paid roughly $3,400 for 5 nights after tax (~$680/night), which got me thinking about whether renting DVC points might get us better sleeping arrangements for a similar price. We own DVC but our points don't return until October 2027, so we'd be renting.
We need at least 3 beds: one for my wife and me, one for her parents, and one for the kids. From what I can tell, that almost certainly means looking at 2-bedroom DVC villas — but everything I'm seeing for Deluxe 2-bedrooms is well over $1,000/night, which blows past our budget.
So I've shifted focus to 1-bedrooms. Most of the DVC 1-bedrooms that sleep 5 seem to offer either a pull-out chair or a Murphy twin as the third sleeping option. This is not a huge upgrade over what we'd have at AoA. I can match or beat the Cars Suite price at a few Deluxe resorts, but the one that really stands out to me is a resort view at BLT which is roughly the same price: 2 bathrooms and access to the Monorail are real draws. But I'm unsure how easy the Resort category is to get via rental, plus being non-refundable isn't appealing.
I know the Family Suites at the other Value Resorts (All-Star) have 3 separate beds and likely come in at a lower price point, which sounds appealing on paper, but the photos make the rooms look noticeably smaller than AoA's suites. For anyone who's stayed in both, is the space sacrifice significant enough to matter for a group our size? I'm also not a fan of bus-only transporation--the skyliner is a big selling point!
Thanks in advance, any firsthand experience with these setups is super helpful!