I get that same burning sensation. I use Neutrogena (sp?) sunblock stick (stick suncreen) that is SPF 25. I have never gotten burned and it never stings. Supposedly better for your skin as well. I reapply it every hour when at the beach all day because I worry about the sunburn factor and my face peeling. I think you could apply it less frequently and be just fine. Here is what it looks like
ETA: When I go to the pool, I just put it on once-no burn. I am very cautious at the beach because I have gotten badly burned from a day at the beach.