The first question for you is do you want to cruise
3 or 4 nights or 7 nights? If you want to do the lesser then the Wonder would be the ship for you. The Magic only sails 7 nighters.
To be perfectly honest- I would say that we like the Wonder better then the Magic but we only do 7 nighters now so the Wonder is out for us!
In 1999- we cruised for the first time and choose the Wonder- it was just a couple of months old. We love Tritons better than Lumieres and we love the Route 66 area. It was also a brand new ship which is amazing. We decided to cruise on the Magic the next year and a couple of months before the cruise- they changed the Magic to 7 nights. SInce then- we have only cruised the Magic since a 3/4 night is to short for us.
You will enjoy either or better yet- BOTH! That way- you can make your own comparsions.
GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!
If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!