We stayed off-site once and NEVER again. I would almost rather not go. It is not worth the hassle. The on-site resorts are all excellent, while off-site are hit-or-miss. So far we have stayed at the All-Star, Poly (my favorite), CR and YC. We are staying at the Dolphin in April because we couldn't resist the price and I knew that Disney would not be offering any discounts during our trip. I was glad to see that Andy posted such a good report on it. I will warn you though, once you stay on-site, it is hard to stay off-site. Good luck. Jay