I went on the 2005 and 2006 DVC cruises.
The 2005 was AWESOME!!
The 2006 not so much!
In 2006 we also went on the Double Dip 7 Day cruise and decided that we prefer the longer itinerary and activities
DCL offered as opposed to depending on DVC to provide the bulk of the entertainment that we may or may not enjoy.
This year, our Aug 2008 15 day repo cost 50% more than it would cost for us to go on the Sep 2008 4 Day DVC cruise. We had Ducky Williams on the ship the entire time, ESPN sportscasters, AJ and Aly, and special shows at night. We received a Litho and some stateroom gifts. DVC had a reception and gave out free alcoholic beverages. We also hit 7 ports.
We missed out on the great onboard add-on incentives, but we are not adding on. If I planned on adding on, I would go on the DVC cruise to do it because they have always offered great incentives onboard.
I just found our 2006 cruise was too focused on sales and not enough activities. Because it's a charter, DVC is supposed to fill the navigator with activities not DCL. They did have their nightly shows and bingo and nightclubs, but the rest was left to DVC who left big gaps of time unfilled.
That and the 2nd stop at
Castaway Cay was delayed by 2 hours so that everyone would attend the saleshow in the theater. By that time, I was tired of sales and marketing.
Im not telling anyone not to go, just giving a dissenting opinion because I feel it's needed. DCL offers great cruises, filled with activities and special guests and gifts. You dont have to go on a DVC cruise to get that.
Also because it's a shorter cruise, and in 2005 we were not
Castaway Club members, we could not get into Palo for Dinner or Brunch. We checked daily.
We also received incentives on our Repo Cruise. We received $50 obc from Disney Visa and $575 Costo Cash card for booking with Costco Travel. That pretty much covered our tips
