Disney lets girl into Winnie's world

edcrbnsoul

DIS Veteran
Joined
Aug 17, 2003
Messages
7,554
Oh good, because Disney doesnt have a enough female Characters, lets take one of the few male leads in their franchise and replace him with a girl.

How long before this nameless girl shows up at a character breakfast with Pooh and friends. Count me among those who thought Poohs world was just fine.


Maybe it's just the impossibly cozy nature of the 'hood, but for 80 years there has been no change in the resident line-up of the Hundred Acre Wood.


Guess who's coming for honey? As part of a barrel-full of Winnie the Pooh anniversary events, Disney is working on a new animated series that will replace Christopher Robin with a 6-year-old girl.


To quote one loquacious Rabbit: "Oh my, oh my, oh my goodness!"


Although the bear's party fare includes much Disney hoopla - anniversary-themed goods, Disney Channel marathons and a stage show that kicks off today in New York - the real bother is sure to be over tinkering with a classic.


Details are sketchy on the as-yet-nameless new arrival, who will make her debut in the 2007 computer-generated series My Friends Tigger and Pooh. Disney execs say the idea is to bring an older audience to an iconic franchise born when British author A.A. Milne began musing about the imaginary world of his son, Christopher Robin.


"We got raised eyebrows even in-house at first, but the feeling was these timeless characters really needed a breath of fresh air that only the introduction of someone new could provide," says Nancy Kanter of the Disney Channel.


The gamble could sweeten the pot of a company that already brings in $1 billion annually from Pooh merchandise, "more than all their core characters combined," says Thomas Ranese of marketing consultants Interbrand. "Pooh appears to be a robust brand that can handle expansion."


There could be a side benefit to luring new kids to this idyllic forest. Because today's tykes often get introduced to literary characters through their cartoon counterparts, "the hope is this will bring more kids to (Pooh) books," says Rory Halperin, who covers entertainment for Child magazine.


But some fans no doubt will feel that Winnie's world was fine just the way it was. "This strikes me as a step too far away from the vision of the original books," says Kathleen Horning, who trains children's book librarians at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. "Besides, growing up, I had no problem relating to Christopher Robin. He almost had a non-specific gender."


Disney's Kanter says the new cartoon represents not an abandonment of an old, familiar world, but rather an alternate universe for Pooh and his crew.


"Christopher Robin is still out there in the woods, playing," she says. "We hope people will fall for this new tomboyish girl. The last thing we want to be is the ones who brought the franchise down."
 
Sure add a girl if thats what they want to do but don't replace Christopher Robin. Additions are fine in my book. Replacements are what bother me.
 

jgmklmhem said:
Sure add a girl if thats what they want to do but don't replace Christopher Robin. Additions are fine in my book. Replacements are what bother me.

::yes:: Exactly
 
Oh no.

Just what Disney needs--more girl characters. I guess boys really are second class citizens in Disney's world.

How fun.
 
I wanted to know what the heck was up with the gopher?!?!?!?
Hey Disney, how about a new idea instead of ruining great stories.
 
I think it's weird; I could understand Christopher Robin might get a new friend or a sister or something like that and introduce her to the Hundred Acre Wood, but is this girl imagining the same place as Christopher Robin is? It doesn't make sense that two separate children would have the exact same fantasy.
 
jgmklmhem said:
Sure add a girl if thats what they want to do but don't replace Christopher Robin. Additions are fine in my book. Replacements are what bother me.
I totally agree.
 
They are already tinkered some with the characters in the Book of Pooh. My kids never liked it....I don't think it was a big hit. They love the classics...I guess that why it is a classic?
 
Laura said:
I think it's weird; I could understand Christopher Robin might get a new friend or a sister or something like that and introduce her to the Hundred Acre Wood, but is this girl imagining the same place as Christopher Robin is? It doesn't make sense that two separate children would have the exact same fantasy.

It's a fantasy? You mean Tigger and Pooh and Piglet and Eeyore aren't real? :confused3
 
CHristopher Robin has to stay-don't replace him!!!!!!
 
But some fans no doubt will feel that Winnie's world was fine just the way it was. "This strikes me as a step too far away from the vision of the original books," says Kathleen Horning, who trains children's book librarians at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. "Besides, growing up, I had no problem relating to Christopher Robin. He almost had a non-specific gender."



Ok, I have to agree with this women. All the charaters are not overwellining apeeling to one gender. The great fun of being of that age, and part of the appeal of Winne the Pooh.

My DD swears piglet is a girl anyway.

I am anorginal Winnie the Pooh fan. For the most part I don't mind the Disney versons, but this is taking things one step too far.

I agree adding a friend of C.R. a little sister would be not so bad. I do not understand would they want to do this? Are they going to try to pass it off has C.R. daughter and he passes the toys on to her?
 
jgmklmhem said:
Sure add a girl if thats what they want to do but don't replace Christopher Robin. Additions are fine in my book. Replacements are what bother me.
::yes::
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom