I have both the one from WDW and the one in the catalog (not the newest one--the first one w/pin and lanyard). By far, the one in the catalog is a much better bag. The WDW got limpy, while the construction of the one from the catalog seems much better. Both bags are identical when it comes to storages in terms of pages and mesh bags. I liked the one in the catalog so much, I just order another one.