Wow, I'm sad to see this store go, but hopefully they will have a good selection in the other locations. And for the AP holders it would be good to have them available at WOD.
As far as prices, they were high on a lot of things, I agree, but I could often find a good deal on items, like candles on sale or candle plates, for less than $5.
I also used to get some towels on every trip (the ones with the Mickey head outlines) as they were not too unreasonably priced. I would bring back a small set of hand towels and some Mickey soap for our house sitter, etc.. and think they weren't that pricey. Hope they will still be carrying these!