Thanks so much! I knew someone here would help! We are planning 2 "big" TS meals. One will be the BBQ and the other will be a character breakfast. Can't decide, can't decide! Minnie & Friends OR Goofy's Kitchen?
The rest of the time during our 4.5 days, we'll eat corndogs and ice cream on main street.

Just kidding (sort of! )
Thanks again!
OctoberDisney -
I have to agree with Goldies 5 - I'm a
big Goofy's Kitchen fan (more the breakfast/brunch, however, and not so much the dinner). In 17 years of eating there I have only a couple of 'off days.' I am one who wants really good food mixed in with some characters. If the characters happen to be on a break or there are very few of them there, at least I know I have good food to eat! The buffet is huge and has a really wide variety of dishes from which to choose. Usually, there are about 7 characters onsite at one time (and that includes a couple of Princesses and whichever character is located at the entrance for photo ops), but I have seen as few as 5 characters and as many as 8 characters. Unfortunately, all of the other character meals (Ariel's Grotto, Critter Breakfast and Surf's Up wth Mickey) have 4 or 5 characters.
But to be fair, Minnie & Friends has more characters than
all of the meals. If characters are your main interest and food is not as much of an issue, Minnie & Friends might be more to your liking. They seem to have anywhere from 8 characters to 14 characters on a given day. M&F has more characters than anywhere else, but the food gets consistently mixed reviews. Some folks say the food is "inedible" or simply "cold." Some folks say they love the food and that they hate Goofy's!

It's all subjective, based on personal tastes and opinions. So it's hard to go by really bad reviews (unless they are repeatedly bad) or really good reviews, because everyone has their own tastes and preferences. What's bad to one person will be great to another person, and vice versa. Some folks like a LOT of characters coming by, to the point where they can't even get a bite of food. I don't like that. I like a good number of characters BUT I like to enjoy my meal as well...which is why Goofy's Kitchen works well for me!
So I think it boils down to if the character aspect outweighs the food aspect. If so, and you want tons of characters, choose Minnie & Friends. You won't be disappointed with the number of characters. If you want anywhere from 5 to 8 characters and a wide variety of tasty food, choose Goofy's.
Here is a link to our dedicated character meal photo thread (a good thing to do is start on the last page and work your way back, so you will see the more recent character sightings first) - this will give you an idea of which characters can be found at which meals:
http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=2234435
And here is a link to Disneynerd420's TR - scroll down to Posts #338 and #339 for a look at all the great food available at Goofy's for breakfast/brunch:
http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=2268157&page=23