For the most part, I agree with HopperFan, but there are several factors that affects the decision for me as well. Me personally, I actually really enjoy the All Stars Resorts. I love the theme, and they're not really spread out resorts so walking around is easy. However, we travel to WDW with kids, and when they were toddlers, All Stars was just fine, as they fit in a double with us, but now that they're bigger, we simply need more space so it's POR for us. I also really love CB's theme and it's one of my favorite mods, but for us it's not worth the money to upgrade from AS until they're done with the refurbs and have queen beds. There are pros and cons with each resort, and it suits people and situations differently. Price, of course, is a huge deciding factor, but I also take into consideration party size (how comfortably will we fit into the room), theme (what are we in the mood for?), and reviews (take them with a grain of salt.)