DIS Dining Experts: WPC, RR, or CJ's at DTD?

[ems_mom]

This September trip to the World will be my fourth in two years. I am the luckiest person ever! I am going with one of my favorite travel companions, my DD 23. We had an excellent experience at WPC two years ago and she has not been to either of the other restaurants. I have eaten at the outside bar area of RR but not the dining room. We have no first hand knowledge of CJ's. (We both love lobster, but the reviews are spotty.) Any advice? Food quality is primary but atmosphere is almost as important. Thanks in advance... I look to the DIS for good advice.

 

[GoofySon'sMom]

We loved Raglan Road. The step dancer wasn't there the night we were there but there was live music which was great. Food was very good. Service was a bit slow, but it didn't bother us because of the music.

We are planning on trying WPC this year but I am hesitant because of the recent lousy reviews.

Not a seafood fan so never been to Capt Jacks ... sorry I can't offer any advice on that one!

 

[cdrn1]

Cap'n Jacks gets some bad reviews, but we ate there last Sept on the dining plan, and it was one of the best meals we had. The crab cakes were out-of-this-world good; we had the lobster tails and they were on the small side, but hey there were two so that was fine. They were tender and good. The desserts were very good as well and we had a cocktail called the Fuzzy Captain that was quite possibly the best I have ever had!! Service was attentive.
We ate at RR that same week and enjoyed that very much as well. We had the Dalkey Duo appetizer and it was delish! The entrees were good but not great but the bread pudding...WOW! The atmosphere was nice and our server was pretty good.