On our first Disney Cruise, on the 4-day Magic way back in 2000, we ended up skipping Palo because we wanted to experience each of the rotation restaurants.
If you really want to try Palo and experience each of the regular rotation restaurants, you could always "double dip" one evening. You could make your Palo reservations for an hour or so after your regular dining time, go to dinner in the rotation restaurant and just have a drink and appetizer (or the whole dinner if you want), and then go to Palo later. That way you really wouldn't miss anything but you would be stuffed!
Or if you don't want to eat twice and want to fully enjoy Palo (I wouldn't be able to control myselg and I'd probably stuff myself by eating 2 meals) go to Barb's website and check out the menus to see if one doesn't appeal to you that much.............but of course you'd miss the atmosphere in one of the dining rooms and they are all so unique!! Good luck!!
Barb's awesome site: www.castawayclub.com
GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!
If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!