We like different character breakfasts for different reasons. We all (my parents, myself, and all three of my kids, 18, 8, 4) think Storytellers has the best food of the breakfast buffets, hands down. That is why is the favorite of my oldest and my parents. My 4 year old son likes it best because "Giant Mickey Mouse" and the other characters he's used to seeing as cartoons on TV seem huge and scary to him. He wants to like them like his big sisters, but he just isn't there yet. He expects animals to be big. So the forest animals and the ranger, that is just a regular person, at Storytellers are less scary for him.
My 8 year old daughter likes Minnie's at the Plaza Inn best because of the character interaction. The rest of think it's good, but it isn't a favorite for anyone else. The character interaction is awesome though!!! Most character bang for your buck!
I like Surf's Up the best because it is the only one with Mickey Mouse (my favorite!!!) and I love the interactive show. I love watching my kids, and all the others, dance with Mickey and the other characters. It makes my heart happy.
You have to decide what's most important to you and your party. How old is everyone? Are you more concerned with great food and nice surroundings? At Storytellers you can go buffet or order off the menu. You can also request anything on the buffet be made fresh (the yolks were overdone on the Eggs Benedict on the buffet and they made my daughter new ones and brought them to our table!!!!). If you're after seeing as many characters as you can head to Minnie's. If, like me, it is all about seeing the Mouse Man himself, then Surf's Up would be your best choice. Oh, and there's always Goofy's. It is our least favorite of the breakfast buffets, but tons of people love it. And I think we'll try it for dinner on our next trip. It is the only character buffet dinner.