Last Dec, I ate at both of them. My friend and I ate at the one in the Marketplace, over by the Disney Christmas store. I love it there...the food is incredible.
Then, later in my stay, another friend and I decided to use the one that's down by the movie theater since we were going to the movie after eating. It was almost awful. On my visit to the one at the Marketplace, I had tried my friend's pizza, and found it to be wonderful. So, when I was at the 'other' one later in the week, I ordered the same pizza for myself. It was so 'not good' that I didn't come close to finishing it. Now...how could the exact same thing be so different at two different places??? And the seating at the second one was not great. Ended up sitting at a counter with people standing there, waiting for us to finish! Won't be going to that one again.