Ditto with the pp, we always stay at the BWPPI because of its location. The rooms are clean and have a variety of different types of rooms to choose from, but some people don't like BWPPI rooms being not so clean. The free continental breakfast at Captain Kidd's is great to have, but its nothing special.
The good thing about BWPPI in your situation is that you can get the two queen bed room with a sofa bed, so you can have three beds in your room and save a little money.
The pool is not big, but it is good enough for people to rest up after a long day at the parks.