Small World!!! I am also in Dayton!
I paid $226.90 when I bought my roundtrip ticket back in March. However, I was really picky about the times I wanted - and got - and neither of those flights have any cheap seats left. My DD, future son-in-law, & DGD are taking the auto train from DC, and will get in mid-morning(?) on December 18th. My non-stop flight leaves Dayton at 11am and lands in Orlando at 1:15pm - just a perfect time for them to pick me up at the airport before we buy groceries and check into our rented villa at 4pm.
Our vacation ends on Jan. 1st, and I scheduled an afternoon flight so I can help DD get everything out of the villa and into their van, so they can drop me at the airport before getting back to the train station mid-afternoon for their journey home. My non-stop return flight leaves Orlando at 3pm & gets into Dayton at 5:20pm. When we first discussed the dates, I could have bought this same ticket for $206.90, but by the time DD got everything settled on her end, the price had gone up. I waited a couple more weeks - and watched it go up even further, before settling back down to $226.90 - at which time I bought my ticket.
Even if I could have saved some money on different flight arrangements, the flight times and non-stop service are definitely worth a little extra to me. (Although, I wouldn't be averse to voluntarily giving up my seat on the return flight in exchange for a free roundtrip ticket to be used at a later date - even if it involves changing planes. At that point my departure and arrival times won't impact anybody else's plans - except my other DD who will be picking me up in Dayton - but she's flexible.)