I was very pleased with the finale. I never cared for Jenn so if someone had to die, she would have been my choice! I actually liked the part about her leaving a baby behind as it stressed the point that life goes on; the whole circle of life thing. Remember Dawson saying that death was not the opposite of life, it was the opposite of birth?
I also much preferred Joey and Pacey rather than Dawson. And I LOVED the way they worked it in that Doug really was a closet gay, as Pacey has been hinting and teasing since the first season.
The only thing that bothered me was that the little girl (Dawson's sister) and the little boy (Alexander, Joey's nephew) appeared to be the same age. Seems to me the boy should have definitely looked older as he was a pre-schooler when Dawson's mom had a baby.
Peggy