For this upcoming trip I am renting points but not from David. I am going through
DVC Rental.
there is also
DVC Rental Store and
Rent my DVC Points all of which are cheaper than David - but not as big. so perhaps they don't have the volume to get what you really want?
There are several chats boards for direct rental but I found it was a bit of a race to get the points before others so I went looking for a broker.
the discount is about 50% compared to the disney rack rate - so yes - cheaper than the usual general public/AP offers. (Although I note WDW UK is once again offering SSR & OKW at 35% off + free dining + 14 day ticket at 7 day price + $100 gift card - which may be getting close. I did this last year through a UK
disney travel agent - too easy)
it really depends on when you want to go. There is a different dynamic to booking DVC than public discounts. e.g. the first week of Dec is "value" season and most rooms go (except SSR and OKW) at the 11 month mark - esp. VWL.
The other dynamic I discovered (is really hard to explain) - The bookings open but only for 7 day bookings. I wanted 8 days - the agent said he had to wait another day before he could book all 8 days and in that one day the AKV room I wanted was gone.
It is hard to split bookings. I don't think Disney are keen, but the agents all have minimums (like 3 days or 50 points)
I will do this again. And through an agent again - but only for 7 days! (did that make sense?)
give it a whirl - but get organised a year in advance - or stay at SSR
Imagine the chaos on DVC rental when GF gets DVC villas!