We did this for my DIL wedding shower but could work for Baby shower too, we got diff. color washcloths (target, cheap) and glycern soap (Bath & Body works $1 each) wrapped the washcloth around the scented soap like an envelop, tied with ribbon and put a little tag on that said "From .... Shower to your" Put them all in a big basket, people loved them, plus they were actually usable, worse thing is getting those dumb little things at a shower that are totally useless. You could do some kind of variation of this with some kind of "baby" associated soap at dollar store.