I've never been a fan of WDW restaurants - mediocre at best. We've been to CP at the end of two long, wet days for dinner and thought there was a great variety; fresh and great tasting food (the only thing missing was a glass of wine).
Last time we went, it was very crowded but we had ADRs. The food was cold and it looked like nothing had been refreshed recently. We were very disappointed. Looks from other posts that our last trip was an abberation - but I am still a bit nervous to go back.