Well, I'm a huge Crocs fan-I live in the Beach style in the summer as well as the Croc Athens and I've been living in the Mammoth this winter. Having said that, I purchased a pair of the Celeste while at Dick's sporting goods. I don't like them. My foot is way too wide (hence the reason why I love the regular Crocs) and I can not wear them for to long a span of time. Sigh. I'm thinking of trying the Mary Janes.