creationism v evolution in the classroom

Well...last year, in Biology, we learned about Evolution, and only Evolution.

But, going to a public school, they couldn't teach us creationism. (schools can't force religion onto their students)

Personally, Catholic/Religious schools should teach creationism (since people there heavily believe in that...) and public schools should teach evolution.

That's just my personal beliefs...

And, I don't believe a word of creationism. No offense to people who do, but I just am not a speck religious.
 
Evolution should be taught in a biology class.
Creationism should be taught in a religious studies class.

That being said, I go to a school whose major focus point is biology. We learn about evolution, not because it's biology related, but because it's required in the state of New Jersey to actually teach it. At the start of the unit, my teacher told us it was required and that we have to go through with it. I can't speak for the other classes, but in my class alone, we have athiests, agnostics, and very religious people. We were able to put aside our beliefs to learn more about this theory.

My school doesn't offer any religious classes (it's a public school), but I'm pretty sure that if we were taught creationism, we'd do the same thing. I think we're old enough to not let our beliefs consume a unit in a class.
 
Creationism should not be taught in a public school. That said, if somebody's religious beliefs are so strong that they can't stand to sit through a science class on evolution, they should be given the right to leave the room.

Creationism is a religious theory and therefore belongs only in religious schools.
 
That said, if somebody's religious beliefs are so strong that they can't stand to sit through a science class on evolution, they should be given the right to leave the room.

I wish we could do that.
I hate sitting through a class listening to something I don't even believe in. It's pointless to me.
 

I don't think Creationism should be taught in science. I agree with Axel, nobody should have to sit through a class about evolution if it's not what they believe in.
 
Neither. Anything that has to do with religion or beleifs in general should be left completely out of the classroom. Schools should teach only the things that are proven to be facts.
 
my main point was: you can learn evolution in school, because it's science. you can learn creationism in your place of worship.
 
I wish we could do that.
I hate sitting through a class listening to something I don't even believe in. It's pointless to me.
Same. That's how I was when my World History teacher was talking about Christianity/Judiasim/Mulism (drawing a blank...)

I wanted to leave the room, because I don't believe in any religion.
 
Evolution should be taught in a biology class.
Creationism should be taught in a religious studies class.

That being said, I go to a school whose major focus point is biology. We learn about evolution, not because it's biology related, but because it's required in the state of New Jersey to actually teach it. At the start of the unit, my teacher told us it was required and that we have to go through with it. I can't speak for the other classes, but in my class alone, we have athiests, agnostics, and very religious people. We were able to put aside our beliefs to learn more about this theory.

My school doesn't offer any religious classes (it's a public school), but I'm pretty sure that if we were taught creationism, we'd do the same thing. I think we're old enough to not let our beliefs consume a unit in a class.

i 100% agree with this post.. as long as the subject is taught objectively and unbiasedly, i dont see the harm... evolution should be taught in a biology class, because it is indeed a science.. it is backed by fossilized proof.. people may argue that it is a theory... yes. it is indeed a theory.. but in science, the word theory is very strong.. a theory is backed by hard facts and is reviewed by numerous people before it can be released as a theory... for example... gravity is still a theory... there are facts that prove it exists.. but theres nothing that completely says gravity exists, because we cant physically see it


creationism is not a theory, however.. its a belief.. it explains things using the bible as a reference point, and not logistical hard facts... it relies more on the supernatural, which is the furthest thing from science.. therefore, it should be taught in a religious studies or philosophy class, and not a science class

either way though, i think its important that these subjects are taught objectively... present their ideas and points to the students.. as long as they arent forced to believe it, i dont see the harm in teaching it.. its always better to clearly know both sides of the fence, before choosing a belief anyway



Same. That's how I was when my World History teacher was talking about Christianity/Judiasim/Mulism (drawing a blank...)

I wanted to leave the room, because I don't believe in any religion.

haha im taking a religion class now, and i find it interesting how similar all of those religions were... i know im going to get flamed for this, but all of those religions are just shells of their former selves now a days... i can go into more detail, but thats another story for another topic lol..

but long story short, its important to learn about other religions, and not just your own... if religious leaders would only enlighten themselves to others beliefs, theyll see how similar all religions are, and most of these civil wars around the world be prevented :)
 
I have a question. Is Religion not taught in Public schools in some states? I thought it was a compulsary lesson, at least it was at my primary and secondary school (Primary school was a CoE school, but the Secondary school wasn't)
 
my main point was: you can learn evolution in school, because it's science. you can learn creationism in your place of worship.

Not everyone can go to a religious school/take a religion class.

Same. That's how I was when my World History teacher was talking about Christianity/Judiasim/Mulism (drawing a blank...)

I wanted to leave the room, because I don't believe in any religion.

Exactly. We should have the opportunity to leave the room if we don't want to listen to something we don't believe in..
 
I have a question. Is Religion not taught in Public schools in some states? I thought it was a compulsary lesson, at least it was at my primary and secondary school (Primary school was a CoE school, but the Secondary school wasn't)
Religion isn't taught at any public school in any state.

"Based on religion, creed, sex, etc, we will not discriminate any student"

And they can't teach religion because not everyone believes in it.
 
Seriously guys, do you get that annoyed when hearing about some religion you don't follow that you want to walk outta the room? Do you wanna leave when you hear about Zeus, Odin, and Ra in your Ancient History class or is it just when you hear about Jesus, Muhammad, and Buddha? Just curious...

In the case of creationism and evolution, you know it's all a theory so why not just take it as one?

And answering someones question about if we learn about religions in public school (George, maybe?) at least in my state we learn about all the modern religions in our geography classes.
 
what i meant is, they can go to their church to learn it.

Okay...But why should I have to sit through a lesson about something I don't believe?

Either teach both views or neither in schools.
 
Seriously guys, do you get that annoyed when hearing about some religion you don't follow that you want to walk outta the room? Do you wanna leave when you hear about Zeus, Odin, and Ra in your Ancient History class or is it just when you hear about Jesus, Muhammad, and Buddha? Just curious...

Personally, I don't mind learning about other religions. I find it interesting actually.
 
but, school is the only place that some can learn about evolution. from my experiences, i have had a lot more opportunities to learn about creationism then i ever had evolution (outside of school)
 
I don't really understand why Religion isn't taught. It's not like you're learning about one Religion altogether, you're learning about multiple Religions. It fascinates me, about how different religions can be similar in some ways, and different in others.

If Religion can't be taught because not everyone believes it, then doesn't that mean Evolution can't be taught, because not everyone believes the theory?
 
but, school is the only place that some can learn about evolution. from my experiences, i have had a lot more opportunities to learn about creationism then i ever had evolution (outside of school)

Not at all of us want to listen to the theory of evolution if we don't believe it..

I don't really understand why Religion isn't taught. It's not like you're learning about one Religion altogether, you're learning about multiple Religions. It fascinates me, about how different religions can be similar in some ways, and different in others.

If Religion can't be taught because not everyone believes it, then doesn't that mean Evolution can't be taught, because not everyone believes the theory?

Different religions are taught in history.
When we were covering Christianity, we went through a phase on Creationism and did a project on it.
At least at my school we did...
 
My school(s) have never taught Creationism...

Christianity/Muslim/Judaism, yes. Mythology, yes. Creationism, never.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom