I've never posted a room report and doubt I ever will. The one and only time that there was something about the room that we felt wasn't up to standard, I called the front desk/maintenance and it was quickly taken care of. FWIW, some of the things that I've read in the room reports seem very picky to me and are probably things I wouldn't notice or let bother me if I did. I have to admit that I haven't read any room reports for well over a year.
The main reason I don't do room reports myself is that IMHO, they tend to encourage people to make specific or excessive room requests (trying to avoid the "bad" rooms/views). I think this sets them up for disappointment. I also feel sorry for the room assigners & front desk CMs - their job is hard enough. Nothing like witnessing the adult in front of you "meltdown" over a room assignment to start off your vacation!
Based on my personal experience,
DVC does a good job maintaining our homes - and they can do even better when we let them know if something isn't right.
floridafam - I'm sure you will enjoy your stay at BWV. We've only stayed in standard views so far (all room sizes), and all have been in good shape. (The rooms are smaller than those at VB, but you proably already know that). The "quieter" rooms tend to be those farthest from the elevators. The only "noise" that we've noticed from our standard views is that from the EPCOT fireworks (which was actually welcome, LOL) and that from children running through the halls. You can minimize that by asking for a room away from the elevators. Also, if your standard view room is close to the elevators, occasionally you may notice a bus idling and sometimes, the people leaving the Boardwalk at the end of the evening are pretty loud. Enjoy your trip!