There are lots of other ways the Mods are different than the values. A coffeemaker is really quite a small thing and is pretty standard in all hotels and resorts that cost upwards of $100 a night. I'll deal with it, I booked it, but really.
Very few budget motels (Motel 6, Knight's Inn, Red Roof Inn, etc.) offer in-room coffee makers. The cost of supplies (filters, cups, sugar & cream, single-serving packages of the coffee itself, etc.) as well as maintenance of the coffee maker (cleaning, repair & replacement) can easily add up to a few bucks per day and when you're operating on tight margins (the average nightly room rate of budget properties is in the $60 range), that's a huge expense.
The values used to be more different from the moderates than they are now. I would rather they keep them cheaper and not continue to add amenities to them. I'd rather they go back in price to under $100 a night, which was the standard for a long time. My fear is if Disney keeps plusing the values, they will keep increasing the price until they are not much of a value.
Ha, yeah sorry about that, when I wrote budget hotels I was thinking of more places like Hampton Inn, Courtyard by Marriott, Hilton Garden Inn, etc. places you can stay at for $100 or so a night. I wasn't really thinking super budget I guess, just budget in correlation to Disney! Just suprised Disney didn't have coffee makers in all their rooms (I've never stayed at a value resort so I didn't know), but I've never been to a hotel without a coffee maker (but I guess I have never actually been to a budget hotel) so I maybe just used the wrong terminology for what I was actually referring to. Sorry!

Disney has added very few amenities to the values since they began the concept
Did you stay in a Suite or in The Little Mermaid(Standard Room)?I found this out after staying for years via DVC and moderate. The only available rooms for a two night add on we're value at AOA. When we walked in the room and saw the lack of a coffee maker I went to the front desk and explained my shock. They sent one up with plenty of coffee. So just ask the front desk and they will provide one.
